Christopher Nolan is infamous for assembling his complex and intricately layered plots like a puzzle, presenting them in such a way that respects the audience’s intelligence while simultaneously indulging their desire for exhilarating escapist entertainment. He tells stories on a tremendously large scale, and it is all too easy to be swept away by the sheer scope of his vision and ambition.
Nolan is concerned with the impulses and paradoxes of human nature, but his characters’ paths are restrained by the conventional tragedy and pessimism of film noir. This research will explore the ideology and moral messages in Nolan’s films, his films’ unique structure and his auteur-ship talent.
“Breaking rules isn’t interesting. It’s making up new ones that keeps things exciting.” – Christopher Nolan
Christopher Nolan, is one of the few directors who can walk into a Hollywood studio with an idea and come out with $200m. As his career progressed from hit-to-hit, Nolan has been increasingly described by journalists as a ‘Blockbuster auteur’. I consider Nolan to be a true auteur, working with constant themes of identity, truth and time, whilst also collaborating with recurrent actors, producers, production members and writers. He fits within the bracket of a “complete filmmaker” in all aspects of pre-production, production and post-production. He prefers to control the directorial process; no second directing unit, just him and the camera.
Nolan has an auteur approach, placing emphasis on his characters and the audience’s relationship over their actions; although the fantasy element plays an important role too, they’re always realistically grounded. The films’ stylistic and thematic attributes have similarities to Nolan’s past and present work. Nolan uses the story of Bruce Wayne to examine our own personal and social identities, harping onto memory and personality as key themes which have been represented in other Nolan films. He uses this with the constant use of his themes, tones and stories that are intellectual, philosophical and sophisticated as well as entertaining.
When watching a Christopher Nolan film, there are few things to look for that would identify it. Let’s call them Nolan’s trademarks as a director. Non-Linear Storytelling is the most important one. What Nolan is probably best known for is that he doesn’t tell his stories linearly. He makes extensive use of flashbacks and flash-forwards to add additional depth and explanation. As such, a common theme is having multiple story threads that link together.
He likes to work with the same actors and crew, showing his personal and creative preference for his entourage. Since the Batman Trilogy, Hans Zimmer has composed the soundtrack for every film. Co-producing with Zimmer, his signature in all his films consist of big sounds and bold scores. We notice throughout his film career, Nolan has worked repeatedly with many outstanding actors such as Michael Caine, seen in The Dark Knight and Interstellar, Cillian Murphy; starring in The Dark Knight and Inception, Anne Hathaway; in The Dark Knight and Interstellar and Joseph Gordon-Levitt; starring in The Dark Knight and Inception. Nolan implements a strong impact towards the personal creative vision of his films proving his auteur-ship.
Nolan, frequently collaborates with his producing-wife, Emma Thomas; she has executively produced every single one of his nine films (including Following). His brother, long-time writer partner Jonathan has worked on all-but three of Nolan’s films. Wally Pfister, his long-time Academy Award winning cinematographer has shot every single one of his films, bar Interstellar and film score legend Hans Zimmer has composed his last six films, along with his editor and production designer, Lee Smith and Nathan Crowley
Therefore, the visual texture of his films remains similar because his principle of photography (cinematographer Wally Pfister) has been the same for all of his films except The Following. The soundscape of his films remains similar because Hans Zimmer has made all of the soundtracks since Batman Begins. Each film of the Batman trilogy has a similar feel to the story because Nolan wrote them all with his brother Jonathan, who also wrote Interstellar and the short story on which Memento is based. There’s also a consistency with the people in front of the camera. Once Nolan finds an actor/actress he likes working with, he often uses them for more than one film. We can say that Nolan implements a strong impact towards the personal creative vision of his films proving his auteur-ship.
Looking at all these elements that make an auteur, Nolan consistently produces stunning, instantly recognisable imagery and always finds innovative ways to tell a story that is visceral and intellectual all at once and after viewing his unique signatures we can say to ourselves, “Oh yes, this is definitely a Christopher Nolan film.”
Christopher Nolan is a filmmaker, but more than a filmmaker, he’s a storyteller. Nolan pushes the medium of film past its traditional boundaries and effectively stimulates the evolution of narrative. He is a master storyteller challenging his audience and his medium.
Starting with his Following, the title’s association with voyeurism is a clear and obvious component of the narrative and themes. Similar to film noir however, “The following…” is also a subjective explanation of past choices and the events that led the young man to his present situation. In Following, Nolan’s first feature, Nolan experiments with the timeline of the story. Nolan’s success in Memento developed from his experimentation in Following. Memento was a new revelation in film and in narrative. Showing how our thoughts could be rationalised visually.
Memento is best-known for being “that film that plays in reverse order” and it solidifies the use of nonlinear storytelling devices as a major component of Nolan’s artistic aesthetic. Memento’s use of colour informs its innovative and distinct non-linear structure, alternating between colour and monochromatic sequences in an effort to orient the audience as to where they currently stand in the timeline.
Guy Pearce delivers a breathlessly fierce performance as a man out to avenge the brutal rape and murder of his wife, despite the fact that he can’t remember what he did two minutes ago. The character of Leonard Shelby is one of the more peculiar protagonists in American cinema– driving a Jaguar he doesn’t remember how he obtained, and wearing an ill-fitting suit that he’s pretty sure he didn’t buy. Incapable of storing memories in his mind, he instead tattoos his flesh as a way to remember the clues he needs to find his wife’s killer. As such, he’s vulnerable to the designs of others with malevolent intentions, and the nature of his illness means that he can’t fully trust any relationship he has.
The Prestige, like Memento, plays sequentially. But it has no chronological pattern. The story unfolds not through casual action, but through recollections of the characters. Using this technique The Prestige accentuates our perception of reality. Memories, like thoughts, don’t always follow a chronological pattern and are often connected by a series of logic. The sequential order of Nolan’s movies have grown beyond the Aristotelian model and transformed it. Nolan is aware of film versus narrative. In The Prestige, just as in Memento, he pushes and challenges the sequential order of the story.
In typical Christopher Nolan style, the story rests on a series of key revelations, many of which become more effective or intriguing when the audience doesn’t yet have full context. However, here, when audiences have some of the heinous secrets of the magicians, we see voyeurism theory. In Nolan’s films, voyeurism and viewer complicity is given to the audiences by letting them access the information that characters do not.
Throughout, The Prestige performs a careful balancing act with the viewer’s sympathies, alternating between the tragic nature of Angier and the overly determined Borden. It’s a single trick of Borden’s called the Transported Man that sends Angier into a consuming jealousy when he can’t figure out how it’s performed. Bale does his usual trick of getting through his lines with a winning mumble, but it’s Jackman’s textured, muted performance that sells The Prestige’s moody pastiche, just another instance where he proves himself to be one the most underappreciated pleasures of Hollywood.
In the film, Nolan uses several “Levels of Intentionality,” to appeal to our “mind-reading capabilities.” The discovery and revelations made throughout The Prestige enlighten and excite Nolan’s audience. Furthermore, the twisting nature of Insomnia’s plot also evokes the revelatory, puzzle-like character of Nolan’s storytelling, which allows him to turn time itself into a compelling narrative and structural device. In the film production design, the overall effect is one of majestic beauty pervaded by gloom and unease, especially so when a heavy fog envelops Dormer during the pivotal raid sequence.
Pacino plays the part that is like a subdued, run-ragged version of his character. A big city cop in a small frontier town. For all his virtues as a man of justice, Dormer is also profoundly corrupt; he plants evidence to justify his own version of events, and even goes so far as to cover up his role in the accidental killing of his own partner. Finch differs from other murder-thriller heavies in that his guilt is never in question, he admits his deed to Dormer openly and without shame, as if it were the most natural thing in the world.
Nolan’s interest lies in Dormer’s struggle to achieve his objectives without sabotaging himself, continuing the tradition he established in both Following and Memento where the fundamentally-compromised nature of his protagonists allows him to better access the psychological underpinnings of their actions.
The psychological plausibility that Batman Begins offers can be demonstrated best by treating the character of Bruce Wayne as a textual case study to whom we can apply psychoanalytic theory. One of the most interesting themes of the film is the exploration of omnipotence and the opposite side of the same coin, impotence, and how this feeds into Bruce Wayne’s development and thoughts about crime. He is unable to grow out of this fantasy of his father’s perfection due to the immortalization of the image caused by the killing of the father and arrested development of Bruce’s omnipotence complex. Following on from this, Bruce’s psychological development allows him to seek father figures who represent qualities of intelligence, dignity and kindness in the form of Alfred, Lucias Fox and Lieutenant Gordon. His search for a replacement father figure is ongoing but is now kept in check by Bruce’s own moral development and his understanding of his real father.
One of the successes of the film is the articulation, through the creation by Bruce Wayne of Batman, of the fear of the potential inability to act appropriately to defend oneself or loved ones when faced with the threat of physical confrontation. Batman Begins taps into this angst and layers it with psychoanalytic overtones which are intertwined with this fear.
To illustrate this in the film, the split between Bruce Wayne and Batman is necessitated. Bruce creates for himself a superficial playboy personality which prevents him from being able to offer the kind of support required by Rachel Dawes in her everyday life beyond her limited need for protection from violence. By the end of the film Rachel recognises that all Bruce’s energy is devoted to ensuring defence and protection against physical aggression and has to tell him that they cannot be together until he is able to give Batman up. In other words, Bruce sacrifices engagement in a mature intimate relationship. This sacrifice is re-evaluated and put to the test in The Dark Knight.
It is implied that unrestrained capitalism is the cause of the inequality and polarisation of wealth distribution which is clearly a problem in Gotham City. The Narrows, an island in the middle of the Gotham River which is home to Arkham Asylum, represents the worst of the poverty stricken social underclass. The relationship between low income and crime is both assumed and stated throughout the picture.
Furthermore the ‘capitalists,’ or those characters that seem to define the ideology, to whom we have access in the film, demonstrate a disregard for corporate social responsibility. The US has a minimal, problematic and disdainful relationship with socially focused political history which means that criticisms of capitalism or inequality are addressed via reference to evil or greedy individuals rather than to a lack of a social or political infrastructure or welfare to which all should be subject as members of society. In this regard Batman Begins is a very American text.
The skilful manipulation of different story strands in The Dark Knight means that Nolan creates a climax in which the stakes and level of excitement could hardly be higher. This skill is also directed to addressing the ethical themes of the film, primarily the analysis of the clash of competing moral philosophies.
The Dark Knight, like most mainstream American cinema, carries and supports a right wing ideological agenda. Batman operates outside of the law and outside of the bounds of accountability to the institutions and civilisations he serves. He is the individual hero who is willing to do the right thing, which is whatever is necessary to stop the enemies of the society he serves. The people, although they do not know it, need a hero willing to work outside the bounds of accountability or the need for popularity, and so they are lied to for their own good.
Nihilism and moral relativism in extreme forms, which one might argue are really one and the same as true moral relativism is not really any kind of morality at all, are depicted as clearly negative and the key ethical philosophies against which our protagonist must fight.
The Dark Knight makes very clear reference to contentious issues in our current state of affairs post 9/11 and policies in the era of The War on Terror. To list some of the most obvious. The representation of the Joker is implicitly, and sometimes explicitly, aligned with our views and depiction of modern Islamic terrorists. He can’t be bargained or reasoned with, he bombs targets of social importance, he posts camcorder video’s of his kidnap victims on the air as they are forced to read out his messages and demands, and he targets his victims almost indiscriminately aiming for the maximum loss of life.
However, Batman’s interrogation of the Joker, in which he locks the police out of the room and brings his full weight of physical force, to the joy of the victim, to beat information out of the Joker is indeed torture. Then, in order finally to catch the Joker, Batman creates a sonar surveillance system which uses mobile phone signals to monitor all of Gotham City, a pretty extreme example of infringement of individual rights to privacy used in the name of gathering intelligence.
The film’s final message is essentially one condoning governmental lies on the grounds that sometimes people deserve more than the truth. This is a very dangerous right wing concept, the idea that people should not be given the truth for their own sake or because they are too stupid or weak to live with or understand it. This undermines the very tenets of democracy such as the freedom of information and the press.
The unique pairing allows the ideological concept of fear to emerge as the central theme of Batman Begins, a pillar upon which every narrative decision can revolve around. Part of what makes The Dark Knight Trilogy so resonant is Nolan’s ability to distill each individual installment into a singular, unifying theme.
In the case of Batman Begins, that theme is fear, it’s an entirely appropriate prism through which to explore the genesis of Batman himself. Indeed, Batman Begins is the first Batman film to truly understand and portray the character’s nature as something that strikes genuine fear in the hearts of criminals.
Batman Begins, and the larger Dark Knight Trilogy, is not content to simply detail the exploits of the iconic hero as he romps through Gotham fighting crime. It aspires to something greater, using its pulp framework to explore heavy ideological concepts.
Easily the most recognisable and influential of all Batman’s various villains, The Joker as manifested in Nolan’s universe is, first and foremost, an agent of chaos. He matches Batman’s theatricality even as he positions himself as the Dark Knight’s philosophical antithesis. He spreads his nihilistic worldview by finding and using the weaknesses that lie in his opponents, turning them against themselves and each other.
Whereas Batman Begins used the idea of fear as its thematic backbone, The Dark Knight organises its narrative around the central theme of chaos. The Joker’s chief objective is to break down the established order by calling attention to the fragility of the ideological pillars that hold it up.
A perfect example of this is the chaos that ensues when The Joker calls on the citizens of Gotham to murder a Wayne employee who is threatening to reveal the identity of Batman. If the man isn’t dead within an hour, he’ll blow up a hospital. Faced with the prospect of losing their loved ones, the citizens of Gotham turn out en masse to eliminate the employee, besieging the police with an overwhelming and unpredictable wave of opposition.
With his vigilante alter-ego firmly established, The Dark Knight naturally inhabits a constant forward flow of time; its story progressing in linear order. That being said, the manipulation of time does serve an important narrative function. The trope of the “ticking clock” is about as cliched as they come, but it’s nonetheless a vital tool to generate suspense for the audience. The Joker incorporates this tool into his own arsenal, using “the ticking clock” as a way to persuade his victims to act against their self-interests or compromise their principles.
The film’s sequence, which could have made for a captivating feature film in its own right, uses the pressure of a ticking clock to effortlessly distill The Dark Knight’s core conflict between civilised society and anarchy to its ideological essence.
Additionally, Nolan’s fondness for cross-cutting between parallel threads of action allows him to manipulate time himself, compressing it into one cosmic instance across sprawling distances. Naturally, this does away with the objective truth that real time provides, but Nolan inherently understands that cinema has the unique ability to subvert the flow of time while uncovering the emotional truth hidden underneath.
In The Dark Knight Rises, the startling revelations and showstopping sequences come so fast and furious that the audience must race just to catch their breath, but that is the magnitude of scale that Nolan has set up for himself. Indeed, nothing less than the threat of Gotham City’s full-stop annihilation will satisfy Nolan’s narrative and thematic requirements.
Batman Begins dealt with the concept of fear, while The Dark Knight focused on the idea of chaos. The Dark Knight Rises’ primary theme is pain, embodied not just in Bane’s brutal methods, but also in Bruce’s quest to overcome his own pain and complete his life’s work as Batman.
Up until this point, Bruce’s pain had been mostly internal, anguishing over the deaths of his parents and Rachel Dawes. Throughout the trilogy, Nolan has taken great care to show the physical toll that the life of a vigilante takes on Bruce’s body. Indeed, the success of Nolan’s entire take on the Batman universe rests on the fact that Batman is not a superhero; that he’s flesh and blood like the rest of us.
Pain defines the limits of Bruce’s physicality, with each successive installment in the trilogy finding those limits constricting ever-tighter. In order to meet the extraordinary challenge of Bane, Bruce must fight through his pain and rise above his physical limits.
The Dark Knight Rises paints a vivid picture of what modern life might look like following the violent overthrow of society; a picture that resonated far more than Nolan could have anticipated, considering the film’s release during the height of the Occupy Wall Street movement.
In provoking the simmering resentment between the various economic classes of society, Bane is able to expose the fragility of the institutions that keep us from the brink of madness. The Dark Knight Rises was released a few months prior to the bottom falling out of the economy at the start of the Great Recession, which sparked a widespread conflagration pitting the poor, working and middle-class population against the wealthy elite class.
More so than he did in the film before it, Nolan structures his climax around a literal ticking clock, that time-honoured movie trope of a bomb counting down to detonation. Considering the inspired turns of story that drove Nolan’s previous two Batman entries. That being said, the ticking clock nonetheless provides a propulsive framework for Nolan to employ his signature cross-cutting techniques, nimbly tracking multiple threads of action and character as they race to save or destroy Gotham.
Nolan had always been fascinated by the experience of dreams, drawing many parallels between the nonlinear logic of dreams-capes to his professional practice as a filmmaker.
Inception is a complex saga of corporate espionage, and about implanting ideas in people’s minds.The film tries to induce a state in the audience where they cannot distinguish between dream and reality, by creating multiple stages of dream within dream scenarios. Since the film constructs a complex web of dreams-capes, dreams within dreams within dreams, Freudian theory has become the predominant mode of analysis. There are striking parallels between how the protagonist seeks the inception of an idea in his target’s mind and how capitalism incepts its ideology into the audience’s minds.
It’s interesting, then, to note that DiCaprio’s portrayal of protagonist Dom Cobb seems to be a fictionalisation of Nolan himself, from his unique intellectual acuity down to the external aspects like a shared hairstyle, goatee, and buttoned-down sartorial sense. Cobb is a reluctant expat with a tragic past, and is given the chance to return to his children in the States by a wealthy Japanese businessman named Saito.
All of the crew’s efforts are focused towards manipulating the emotions of Robert Fischer, the petulant heir to a vast business empire. They must suspend his disbelief while appealing to his emotion, to the extent that they eventually bring him into the heist himself as an active participant. Knowing all this, it becomes clear that Fischer is akin to the audience, albeit a particularly savvy one that’s seen it all before and stands resistant to cinema’s transcendent charms.
Visually speaking, Inception is arguably Nolan’s most audacious work, filled to the brim with wild, impossible imagery. The narrative affords Nolan the opportunity to explore and indulge in his fascination with the mechanics of time in a comprehensive and integral manner– befitting their place in a heist film, Cobb’s crew naturally races against a ticking clock, but they are uniquely positioned to alter the bounds of the race itself. Inception’s unique take on the mechanics of time is a singular signature of Nolan’s.
In a film loaded with symbolic imagery, the closing image of a top spinning on the table is arguably Inception’s most provoking one. The audience finds itself left on a sharply ambiguous final note, and an extremely frustrating one for those who prefer their movies to spell everything out for them. Is Cobb truly free of his dreams, or is he still trapped somewhere in his unconscious?
The question has inspired numerous armchair detectives to suss out an objective truth, most investigations point to Cobb’s wedding ring as his personal totem, and the film’s key signifier as to whether or not we are currently in a dream state. Cobb sports his ring in the dream sequences, but in his waking reality he appears without it. When he lands in Los Angeles at the end of the film, he’s not wearing his ring.
Far from a final “gotcha” twist, the film’s ending arguably hits a precise note, cementing the film’s murky ambiguity between dreams and waking reality while challenging his audience with the notion that our own realities can be just as subjective.
In Interstellar, the world, simply put, must be saved– but this time, the responsibility falls not to superheroes but to scientists and mathematicians. We begin in the back half of the 21st century, where the mounting effects of pollution, industrialisation, and other byproducts of modern civilisation have ravaged the earth.
In America’s blight-plagued heartland, where a new Dust Bowl rages with increasing intensity, an ex-pilot turned corn farmer named Cooper is trying to eke out a hardscrabble existence with his two children and father-in-law. Cooper is a widower; cursed to wander the rest of his life without his mate. Also like those characters, he’s whip-smart and resourceful; a natural-born leader with bottomless reserves of courage and a ferocious commitment to his family.
More than just a potential love interest for Cooper, Brand is a conduit through which Nolan presents one of Interstellar’s key ideas, the idea of “love” as a powerful, quantifiable cosmic concept. In other words: the idea of “love” being a separate dimension unto itself that can transcend and influence time, space, and gravity.
Last but not least, Dunkirk was structured less as a conventional war film and more like a harrowing survival thriller, it recreates the evacuation of Allied forces from the eponymous coastal town in France as an awe-inspiring story of unfathomable courage and frenzied survival, despite the event itself serving as a tactical loss for the good guys. This snatching of an emotional victory from the jaws of strategic defeat is precisely the sort of peculiar irony that attracted Nolan to the story.
Dunkirk takes a decentralised approach to its plot, trashing the idea of a singular protagonist in favour of enigmatic figureheads; fictional composites instead of historical accounts. They have names, to be sure, but we as an audience don’t have the luxury of time to learn them when our very survival is at stake. I say “our survival” because Nolan intends for these characters to simply serve as windows for the audience to immerse themselves in the harrowing sweep of history as it unfolds. We never see beyond this limited, subjective perspective, we’re stuck with the Allied forces on the ground, forced to flee with them as chaos and destruction surrounding us.
Indeed, time, the device of the ticking clock, unifies the thematic whole of Dunkirk, placing the film as an exploratory apex within Nolan’s career. Again, the story essentially functions as one large escape sequence, with the Allied forces racing against the clock from the encroaching German menace as they try to get off the beaches of Dunkirk and safely across the English Channel.
In a time where critics and audiences alike conflate movies with television and vice-versa as one indistinguishable medium, Nolan’s lifelong quest to preserve the sanctity of the movie-house and extoll its superiority to the home theatre has never been more urgent. Nolan’s films are nothing less than a shot across the bow, a slap upside the head that compels us to remember what makes the communal moviegoer experience such a special one.
Christopher Nolan is a great analyst of the “human soul” and the forces that drive men to go to the extremes of either horror or grandeur. He deals with male characters’ psychology is tremendous. These men are always complex, tortured, torn between good and evil, frantically mad or in a breathless search for justice. The subtleties and intricacies of their many layers can only be commended.
As soon as we turn to his female characters, we are quickly forced to admit that they are one-sided, one-dimensional, archetypal roles, with often no other purpose than to push the male hero in one direction or the other. They have no complexity or motivation. Sometimes, as in the case of Insomnia, they purely don’t exist at all.
In The Prestige, Angier and Borden’s murderous rivalry starts with Angier’s wife dying; in Memento, Guy Pearce’s character’s only motivation is to find his wife’s killer; in Insomnia, the original investigation begins with the murder of a teenage girl; in Inception, Dom Cobb is eaten alive by the memory of his wife’s suicide; in Dark Knight, Rachel’s death creates the crucial Two-Face character, etc.
The women who remain alive are blatantly excluded from Nolan’s favourite themes of obsession, search for purpose, crucial moral dilemmas and, of course, also the one he is so skilled at depicting, an epic duel between two men which often ends in death. Also, in Memento, many viewers in fact struggle to remember Natalie’s name or function in the film some time after seeing it. She is only a means to an end, showing the viewer how deeply Leonard’s condition affects him. In Insomnia and Dunkirk, in the manly struggle a woman appears to have no place.
Moreover, in Inception, the cast is almost entirely made of men. That team of extremely clever scientists, doctors and businessmen contains only one woman, Ellen Page, the clever-but-unattractive sidekick. She has no other purpose than to be beautiful and tragic. She is not strong-minded or particularly intelligent, she is a depressed wife and mother. Also, in Batman Begins, there are eight main characters and amongst them one woman, one woman who is essentially Bruce’s love interest and she is transformed into a mere element of a love triangle and the necessary victim halfway through the movie. Looks like Gotham City is a man’s, man’s, man’s world. Even Selina Kyle, she is not more than the sexy cat-woman in a tight leather suit using her charms to fool men.
The problem with Nolan’s women is that they are used as a means to glorify his men. Maybe one-dimensional female characters are the way for male characters to appear so well written. So all in all, Nolan loves killing off wives. But this feminist isn’t ready to write-off Nolan’s cinematic sensibilities just yet. It is said that behind every great man lies a woman, and this is certainly true in the case of a Nolan-directed flick.
However, to delight his audiences, Nolan adapted the script to his own liking, and transformed the character of Murphy, Interstellar’s co-protagonist, 10 year old, into a daughter, not a son.
Let’s get back to Inception. The feminine threat of it reveals itself as coming from a masculine force. This offers another chance to display gender as performed; Cobb’s subconscious contains a significant feminine presence, which he does not display but does at least possess. The public self can be hyper-masculine while the body still hosts multiple gender identities.
Next, this complicates the already mentioned understanding of the stabbing shot of Ariadne. The last note of interest is how this interacts with Deakin’s claims. To him, Mal’s character is the current iteration of Nolan’s “seeming myopic sense of female malignity”. The movie certainly introduces her that way, but over time her villainy becomes a product of Cobb, as an invention of either his mind or victim of his first attempt at inception. Male mistakes causing guilt in the male subconscious does not seem to be a cause for “female malignity” of any sort.
Right after that shot comes the scene where the camera accepts Ariadne’s visual perspective but not Cobb’s. Rather than let the camera return to male perspective, the movie rejects it. That conversation prompts Ariadne’s inclusion in the dream layers for the Inception mission, and she ultimately guides Cobb to a reunion with his children.
Representation here means not the presence of women, which Hollywood already has, but the on-screen portrayal of femininity as something other than the object of male desire or subject of the male gaze. That is not to say that Mulvey and her advocates’ argument is simple, as much as to say that the actual shots of the film complicate the outlined narrative.
Nolan utilises the magic of film giving the audience only a taste of everything without foregoing too much, making the audience aware of the fake medium but revealing a genuine truth. A cut to a Parisian Café allows the audience to believe our characters arrived at their destination logically and that they’re dining in a city familiar to us. Later, it is revealed to the audience the character’s actual method of transportation was a dream. Nolan uses a cut to move us from scene to scene fully aware that the audience has learned to make logical assumptions about a feature’s continuity based on the exposure to previous films. Nolan’s breaking of the audience’s assumptions heightens the viewer’s awareness of themselves as a viewer and intensifies their awareness of the art they are viewing. We learn we exit and enter the dream world throughout the film. Nolan edits the audience into a dream. He uses this technique to force the audience to decipher reality from the dream and exploit the story by capitalising on the medium itself.
Our filmmaker challenges the audience and the art of film, never clearly identifying the transition between reality and the dream. Nolan pushes film, progressing and evolving the medium, and refining the art of the narrative, taking it beyond its traditions into the next stage of storytelling.
Inception, like Memento, is concerned with the mysterious sprawl inside the mind and memory, and like Following and Insomnia, its dream-heist plot sports some questionable ethics. But at its heart lies a man who is hounded by loss and guilt. He lets that guilt chase him into hell and jeopardise the lives of others, but ultimately he chooses the reality of his partners over the tempting fantasy of a dream world. In The Prestige, deception is the only beauty in a bleak world. In Inception, the hero sacrifices a fabricated love for a fuller reality with his family. Both films show that, post-Batman, Nolan’s response to evil has grown out of brainteasers and into a weighty moral maturity.
In addition, The Dark Knight resists moralising. It is not a mere allegory or clash of the ideological titans. There are archetypes here, ethical puzzles, downfall, and sacrifice; there is no doubt that Nolan has created a deeply moral film, forcing us to contend with evil in every scene. “Batman” is not a superhero but a hard-won vocation; Batman is Bruce’s vehicle for his social outrage.
For Nolan, the villains are not wrong to believe that people are corruptible. They are wrong to believe that people are past redemption. We have inherited Gotham, a once-great metropolis that we let go to the dogs. Harvey tells us that “you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain,” and we watch it become his story. In Nolan’s Gotham, humans fail. Bruce tries to enact his own human justice with a gun, but it was too small, too bleak. He needed to become more than a man to give us a justice worthy of the best in humans, and able to withstand the worst.
Finally, Nolan’s Inception is an implicit critique of ideology in a capitalist system. It exposes the ideological and mythological character of capitalism through its evocation of dreams and memory, the substrate of the unconscious that forms the core of individual subjectivity. Nolan’s fascination with time is also represented by his usage of montage and cross-cutting in pursuit of a subjective emotional experience and the building of dramatic intensity.
Nolan’s films explore and subvert our perception of time in pursuit of a greater, unified statement about the subjectivity and fragility of our individual realities, there is no single objective truth in his films, no matter how hard his characters search for it. Perhaps that’s why his protagonists are always so tortured or burdened with regret … they’ve devoted the entirety of themselves to the pursuit of something they ultimately can never attain.
Bibliography:
- G.S. Perno. (2014). Directors’ Trademarks: Christopher Nolan. Available: https://www.cinelinx.com/movie-news/movie-stuff/directors-trademarx-christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
- Dan Lewsey. (2017). Christopher Nolan: An Auteur, or Just Another Filmmaker?. Available: http://danlewsey.com/christophernolan/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
- (2020). Application of Auteur Theory to Christopher Nolan. Available: https://www.ukessays.com/essays/film-studies/application-of-auteur-theory-to-christopher-nolan.php. Last accessed 01/04/20.
- Mary Wild. (2017). The Auteur Rises: Christopher Nolan and Dunkirk on Film. Available: https://www.citylit.ac.uk/blog/auteur-rises-christopher-nolan-and-dunkirk-film. Last accessed 01/04/20.
- Jacqui Griffin. (2017). A Quick Guide To Auteur Theory. Available: https://www.filminquiry.com/quick-guide-auteur-theory/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
- Narrativeinart. (2011). Narrative In Art – Christopher Nolan. Available: https://narrativeinart.wordpress.com/nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Cameron Beyl. (2020). Directors Series: Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk. Available: https://indiefilmhustle.com/dunkirk-christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Cameron Beyl. (2017). Christopher Nolan: The Ultimate Guide to His Films and Directing Techniques. Available: https://indiefilmhustle.com/christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Leon Saunders Calvert . (2010). How Christopher Nolan made Batman grow up. Available: https://offscreen.com/view/nolan_batman. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- AMANDA MARCOTTE. (2012). The Masked Morality of the Batman Trilogy. Available: https://prospect.org/culture/masked-morality-batman-trilogy/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Lauren Wilford. (2012). BLEAKNESS AND RICHNESS: CHRISTOPHER NOLAN ON HUMAN NATURE. Available: https://theotherjournal.com/2012/04/17/bleakness-and-richness-christopher-nolan-on-human-nature/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Andrew Kania. (2014). THE TWISTED FEMMES FATALES OF CHRISTOPHER NOLAN. Available: https://aestheticsforbirds.com/2014/06/01/the-twisted-femmes-fatales-of-christopher-nolan-by-andrew-kania/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Anna Kessler. (2012). It’s a man’s man’s man’s world… The cinema of Christopher Nolan. Available: https://thefword.org.uk/2012/10/films_of_christopher_nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- David Foster Wallace. (2016). Inception, Gender Politics, and Perspective: Answering the Masculine Malaise. Available: https://sites.williams.edu/engl-117-fall16/uncategorized/inception-gender-politics-and-perspective-answering-the-masculine-malaise/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- ANNA KLASSEN. (2014). Christopher Nolan’s Feminist ‘Interstellar’ Isn’t His First Pro-Women Film. Available: https://www.bustle.com/articles/46389-christopher-nolans-feminist-interstellar-isnt-his-first-pro-women-film. Last accessed 01/06/20.
- Brent Cowley, B.A. B.S.. (2017). THE PSYCHOLOGY OF A DARK KNIGHT. In: “REALITY” WHILE DREAMING IN A LABYRINTH: CHRISTOPER NOLAN AS REALIST AUTEUR. digital.library.unt.edu: . 53-57.