Christopher Nolan, non classical storyteller, non transient auteur

Christopher Nolan is infamous for assembling his complex and intricately layered plots like a puzzle, presenting them in such a way that respects the audience’s intelligence while simultaneously indulging their desire for exhilarating escapist entertainment. He tells stories on a tremendously large scale, and it is all too easy to be swept away by the sheer scope of his vision and ambition.

Nolan is concerned with the impulses and paradoxes of human nature, but his characters’ paths are restrained by the conventional tragedy and pessimism of film noir. This research will explore the ideology and moral messages in Nolan’s films, his films’ unique structure and his auteur-ship talent.

“Breaking rules isn’t interesting. It’s making up new ones that keeps things exciting.” – Christopher Nolan

Christopher Nolan, is one of the few directors who can walk into a Hollywood studio with an idea and come out with $200m. As his career progressed from hit-to-hit, Nolan has been increasingly described by journalists as a ‘Blockbuster auteur’. I consider Nolan to be a true auteur, working with constant themes of identity, truth and time, whilst also collaborating with recurrent actors, producers, production members and writers. He fits within the bracket of a “complete filmmaker” in all aspects of pre-production, production and post-production. He prefers to control the directorial process; no second directing unit, just him and the camera.

Nolan has an auteur approach, placing emphasis on his characters and the audience’s relationship over their actions; although the fantasy element plays an important role too, they’re always realistically grounded. The films’ stylistic and thematic attributes have similarities to Nolan’s past and present work. Nolan uses the story of Bruce Wayne to examine our own personal and social identities, harping onto memory and personality as key themes which have been represented in other Nolan films. He uses this with the constant use of his themes, tones and stories that are intellectual, philosophical and sophisticated as well as entertaining.

When watching a Christopher Nolan film, there are few things to look for that would identify it. Let’s call them Nolan’s trademarks as a director. Non-Linear Storytelling is the most important one. What Nolan is probably best known for is that he doesn’t tell his stories linearly. He makes extensive use of flashbacks and flash-forwards to add additional depth and explanation. As such, a common theme is having multiple story threads that link together.

He likes to work with the same actors and crew, showing his personal and creative preference for his entourage. Since the Batman Trilogy, Hans Zimmer has composed the soundtrack for every film. Co-producing with Zimmer, his signature in all his films consist of big sounds and bold scores. We notice throughout his film career, Nolan has worked repeatedly with many outstanding actors such as Michael Caine, seen in The Dark Knight and Interstellar, Cillian Murphy; starring in The Dark Knight and Inception, Anne Hathaway; in The Dark Knight and Interstellar and Joseph Gordon-Levitt; starring in The Dark Knight and Inception. Nolan implements a strong impact towards the personal creative vision of his films proving his auteur-ship.

Nolan, frequently collaborates with his producing-wife, Emma Thomas; she has executively produced every single one of his nine films (including Following). His brother, long-time writer partner Jonathan has worked on all-but three of Nolan’s films. Wally Pfister, his long-time Academy Award winning cinematographer has shot every single one of his films, bar Interstellar and film score legend Hans Zimmer has composed his last six films, along with his editor and production designer, Lee Smith and Nathan Crowley

Therefore, the visual texture of his films remains similar because his principle of photography (cinematographer Wally Pfister) has been the same for all of his films except The Following. The soundscape of his films remains similar because Hans Zimmer has made all of the soundtracks since Batman Begins. Each film of the Batman trilogy has a similar feel to the story because Nolan wrote them all with his brother Jonathan, who also wrote Interstellar and the short story on which Memento is based. There’s also a consistency with the people in front of the camera. Once Nolan finds an actor/actress he likes working with, he often uses them for more than one film. We can say that Nolan implements a strong impact towards the personal creative vision of his films proving his auteur-ship.

Looking at all these elements that make an auteur, Nolan consistently produces stunning, instantly recognisable imagery and always finds innovative ways to tell a story that is visceral and intellectual all at once and after viewing his unique signatures we can say to ourselves, “Oh yes, this is definitely a Christopher Nolan film.”

Christopher Nolan is a filmmaker, but more than a filmmaker, he’s a storyteller.  Nolan pushes the medium of film past its traditional boundaries and effectively stimulates the evolution of narrative. He is a master storyteller challenging his audience and his medium.

Starting with his Following, the title’s association with voyeurism is a clear and obvious component of the narrative and themes. Similar to film noir however, “The following…” is also a subjective explanation of past choices and the events that led the young man to his present situation. In Following, Nolan’s first feature, Nolan experiments with the timeline of the story.  Nolan’s success in Memento developed from his experimentation in Following.  Memento was a new revelation in film and in narrative.  Showing how our thoughts could be rationalised visually.

Memento is best-known for being “that film that plays in reverse order” and it solidifies the use of nonlinear storytelling devices as a major component of Nolan’s artistic aesthetic. Memento’s use of colour informs its innovative and distinct non-linear structure, alternating between colour and monochromatic sequences in an effort to orient the audience as to where they currently stand in the timeline.

Guy Pearce delivers a breathlessly fierce performance as a man out to avenge the brutal rape and murder of his wife, despite the fact that he can’t remember what he did two minutes ago. The character of Leonard Shelby is one of the more peculiar protagonists in American cinema– driving a Jaguar he doesn’t remember how he obtained, and wearing an ill-fitting suit that he’s pretty sure he didn’t buy. Incapable of storing memories in his mind, he instead tattoos his flesh as a way to remember the clues he needs to find his wife’s killer.  As such, he’s vulnerable to the designs of others with malevolent intentions, and the nature of his illness means that he can’t fully trust any relationship he has.

The Prestige, like Memento, plays sequentially. But it has no chronological pattern.  The story unfolds not through casual action, but through recollections of the characters. Using this technique The Prestige accentuates our perception of reality.  Memories, like thoughts, don’t always follow a chronological pattern and are often connected by a series of logic. The sequential order of Nolan’s movies have grown beyond the Aristotelian model and transformed it.  Nolan is aware of film versus narrative.  In The Prestige, just as in Memento, he pushes and challenges the sequential order of the story.

In typical Christopher Nolan style, the story rests on a series of key revelations, many of which become more effective or intriguing when the audience doesn’t yet have full context. However, here, when audiences have some of the heinous secrets of the magicians, we see voyeurism theory. In Nolan’s films, voyeurism and viewer complicity is given to the audiences by letting them access the information that characters do not.

Throughout, The Prestige performs a careful balancing act with the viewer’s sympathies, alternating between the tragic nature of Angier and the overly determined Borden. It’s a single trick of Borden’s called the Transported Man that sends Angier into a consuming jealousy when he can’t figure out how it’s performed. Bale does his usual trick of getting through his lines with a winning mumble, but it’s Jackman’s textured, muted performance that sells The Prestige’s moody pastiche, just another instance where he proves himself to be one the most underappreciated pleasures of Hollywood.

In the film, Nolan uses several “Levels of Intentionality,” to appeal to our “mind-reading capabilities.”  The discovery and revelations made throughout The Prestige enlighten and excite Nolan’s audience. Furthermore, the twisting nature of Insomnia’s plot also evokes the revelatory, puzzle-like character of Nolan’s storytelling, which allows him to turn time itself into a compelling narrative and structural device. In the film production design, the overall effect is one of majestic beauty pervaded by gloom and unease, especially so when a heavy fog envelops Dormer during the pivotal raid sequence.

Pacino plays the part that is like a subdued, run-ragged version of his character. A big city cop in a small frontier town. For all his virtues as a man of justice, Dormer is also profoundly corrupt; he plants evidence to justify his own version of events, and even goes so far as to cover up his role in the accidental killing of his own partner.  Finch differs from other murder-thriller heavies in that his guilt is never in question, he admits his deed to Dormer openly and without shame, as if it were the most natural thing in the world.

 

Nolan’s interest lies in Dormer’s struggle to achieve his objectives without sabotaging himself, continuing the tradition he established in both Following and Memento where the fundamentally-compromised nature of his protagonists allows him to better access the psychological underpinnings of their actions.

The psychological plausibility that Batman Begins offers can be demonstrated best by treating the character of Bruce Wayne as a textual case study to whom we can apply psychoanalytic theory. One of the most interesting themes of the film is the exploration of omnipotence and the opposite side of the same coin, impotence, and how this feeds into Bruce Wayne’s development and thoughts about crime. He is unable to grow out of this fantasy of his father’s perfection due to the immortalization of the image caused by the killing of the father and arrested development of Bruce’s omnipotence complex. Following on from this, Bruce’s psychological development allows him to seek father figures who represent qualities of intelligence, dignity and kindness in the form of Alfred, Lucias Fox and Lieutenant Gordon. His search for a replacement father figure is ongoing but is now kept in check by Bruce’s own moral development and his understanding of his real father.

One of the successes of the film is the articulation, through the creation by Bruce Wayne of Batman, of the fear of the potential inability to act appropriately to defend oneself or loved ones when faced with the threat of physical confrontation. Batman Begins taps into this angst and layers it with psychoanalytic overtones which are intertwined with this fear.

To illustrate this in the film, the split between Bruce Wayne and Batman is necessitated. Bruce creates for himself a superficial playboy personality which prevents him from being able to offer the kind of support required by Rachel Dawes in her everyday life beyond her limited need for protection from violence. By the end of the film Rachel recognises that all Bruce’s energy is devoted to ensuring defence and protection against physical aggression and has to tell him that they cannot be together until he is able to give Batman up. In other words, Bruce sacrifices engagement in a mature intimate relationship. This sacrifice is re-evaluated and put to the test in The Dark Knight.

It is implied that unrestrained capitalism is the cause of the inequality and polarisation of wealth distribution which is clearly a problem in Gotham City. The Narrows, an island in the middle of the Gotham River which is home to Arkham Asylum, represents the worst of the poverty stricken social underclass. The relationship between low income and crime is both assumed and stated throughout the picture.

Furthermore the ‘capitalists,’ or those characters that seem to define the ideology, to whom we have access in the film, demonstrate a disregard for corporate social responsibility. The US has a minimal, problematic and disdainful relationship with socially focused political history which means that criticisms of capitalism or inequality are addressed via reference to evil or greedy individuals rather than to a lack of a social or political infrastructure or welfare to which all  should be subject as members of society. In this regard Batman Begins is a very American text.

The skilful manipulation of different story strands in The Dark Knight means that Nolan creates a climax in which the stakes and level of excitement could hardly be higher. This skill is also directed to addressing the ethical themes of the film, primarily the analysis of the clash of competing moral philosophies.

The Dark Knight, like most mainstream American cinema, carries and supports a right wing ideological agenda. Batman operates outside of the law and outside of the bounds of accountability to the institutions and civilisations he serves. He is the individual hero who is willing to do the right thing, which is whatever is necessary to stop the enemies of the society he serves. The people, although they do not know it, need a hero willing to work outside the bounds of accountability or the need for popularity, and so they are lied to for their own good.

Nihilism and moral relativism in extreme forms, which one might argue are really one and the same as true moral relativism is not really any kind of morality at all, are depicted as clearly negative and the key ethical philosophies against which our protagonist must fight.

The Dark Knight makes very clear reference to contentious issues in our current state of affairs post 9/11 and policies in the era of The War on Terror. To list some of the most obvious.  The representation of the Joker is implicitly, and sometimes explicitly, aligned with our views and depiction of modern Islamic terrorists. He can’t be bargained or reasoned with, he bombs targets of social importance, he posts camcorder video’s of his kidnap victims on the air as they are forced to read out his messages and demands, and he targets his victims almost indiscriminately aiming for the maximum loss of life.

However, Batman’s interrogation of the Joker, in which he locks the police out of the room and brings his full weight of physical force, to the joy of the victim, to beat information out of the Joker is indeed torture. Then, in order finally to catch the Joker, Batman creates a sonar surveillance system which uses mobile phone signals to monitor all of Gotham City, a pretty extreme example of infringement of individual rights to privacy used in the name of gathering intelligence.

The film’s final message is essentially one condoning governmental lies on the grounds that sometimes people deserve more than the truth. This is a very dangerous right wing concept, the idea that people should not be given the truth for their own sake or because they are too stupid or weak to live with or understand it. This undermines the very tenets of democracy such as the freedom of information and the press.

The unique pairing allows the ideological concept of fear to emerge as the central theme of Batman Begins, a pillar upon which every narrative decision can revolve around.  Part of what makes The Dark Knight Trilogy so resonant is Nolan’s ability to distill each individual installment into a singular, unifying theme.

In the case of Batman Begins, that theme is fear, it’s an entirely appropriate prism through which to explore the genesis of Batman himself. Indeed, Batman Begins is the first Batman film to truly understand and portray the character’s nature as something that strikes genuine fear in the hearts of criminals.

Batman Begins, and the larger Dark Knight Trilogy, is not content to simply detail the exploits of the iconic hero as he romps through Gotham fighting crime.  It aspires to something greater, using its pulp framework to explore heavy ideological concepts.

Easily the most recognisable and influential of all Batman’s various villains, The Joker as manifested in Nolan’s universe is, first and foremost, an agent of chaos.  He matches Batman’s theatricality even as he positions himself as the Dark Knight’s philosophical antithesis.  He spreads his nihilistic worldview by finding and using the weaknesses that lie in his opponents, turning them against themselves and each other.

Whereas Batman Begins used the idea of fear as its thematic backbone, The Dark Knight organises its narrative around the central theme of chaos. The Joker’s chief objective is to break down the established order by calling attention to the fragility of the ideological pillars that hold it up.

A perfect example of this is the chaos that ensues when The Joker calls on the citizens of Gotham to murder a Wayne employee who is threatening to reveal the identity of Batman.  If the man isn’t dead within an hour, he’ll blow up a hospital.  Faced with the prospect of losing their loved ones, the citizens of Gotham turn out en masse to eliminate the employee, besieging the police with an overwhelming and unpredictable wave of opposition.

With his vigilante alter-ego firmly established, The Dark Knight naturally inhabits a constant forward flow of time; its story progressing in linear order.  That being said, the manipulation of time does serve an important narrative function.  The trope of the “ticking clock” is about as cliched as they come, but it’s nonetheless a vital tool to generate suspense for the audience. The Joker incorporates this tool into his own arsenal, using “the ticking clock” as a way to persuade his victims to act against their self-interests or compromise their principles.

The film’s sequence, which could have made for a captivating feature film in its own right, uses the pressure of a ticking clock to effortlessly distill The Dark Knight’s core conflict between civilised society and anarchy to its ideological essence.

Additionally, Nolan’s fondness for cross-cutting between parallel threads of action allows him to manipulate time himself, compressing it into one cosmic instance across sprawling distances.  Naturally, this does away with the objective truth that real time provides, but Nolan inherently understands that cinema has the unique ability to subvert the flow of time while uncovering the emotional truth hidden underneath.

In The Dark Knight Rises, the startling revelations and showstopping sequences come so fast and furious that the audience must race just to catch their breath, but that is the magnitude of scale that Nolan has set up for himself.  Indeed, nothing less than the threat of Gotham City’s full-stop annihilation will satisfy Nolan’s narrative and thematic requirements.

Batman Begins dealt with the concept of fear, while The Dark Knight focused on the idea of chaos.  The Dark Knight Rises’ primary theme is pain, embodied not just in Bane’s brutal methods, but also in Bruce’s quest to overcome his own pain and complete his life’s work as Batman.

Up until this point, Bruce’s pain had been mostly internal, anguishing over the deaths of his parents and Rachel Dawes. Throughout the trilogy, Nolan has taken great care to show the physical toll that the life of a vigilante takes on Bruce’s body.  Indeed, the success of Nolan’s entire take on the Batman universe rests on the fact that Batman is not a superhero; that he’s flesh and blood like the rest of us.

Pain defines the limits of Bruce’s physicality, with each successive installment in the trilogy finding those limits constricting ever-tighter.  In order to meet the extraordinary challenge of Bane, Bruce must fight through his pain and rise above his physical limits.

The Dark Knight Rises paints a vivid picture of what modern life might look like following the violent overthrow of society;  a picture that resonated far more than Nolan could have anticipated, considering the film’s release during the height of the Occupy Wall Street movement.

In provoking the simmering resentment between the various economic classes of society, Bane is able to expose the fragility of the institutions that keep us from the brink of madness. The Dark Knight Rises was released a few months prior to the bottom falling out of the economy at the start of the Great Recession, which sparked a widespread conflagration pitting the poor, working and middle-class population against the wealthy elite class.

More so than he did in the film before it, Nolan structures his climax around a literal ticking clock, that time-honoured movie trope of a bomb counting down to detonation. Considering the inspired turns of story that drove Nolan’s previous two Batman entries. That being said, the ticking clock nonetheless provides a propulsive framework for Nolan to employ his signature cross-cutting techniques, nimbly tracking multiple threads of action and character as they race to save or destroy Gotham.

Nolan had always been fascinated by the experience of dreams, drawing many parallels between the nonlinear logic of dreams-capes to his professional practice as a filmmaker.

Inception is a complex saga of corporate espionage, and about implanting ideas in people’s minds.The film tries to induce a state in the audience where they cannot distinguish between dream and reality, by creating multiple stages of dream within dream scenarios. Since the film constructs a complex web of dreams-capes, dreams within dreams within dreams, Freudian theory has become the predominant mode of analysis. There are striking parallels between how the protagonist seeks the inception of an idea in his target’s mind and how capitalism incepts its ideology into the audience’s minds.

It’s interesting, then, to note that DiCaprio’s portrayal of protagonist Dom Cobb seems to be a fictionalisation of Nolan himself, from his unique intellectual acuity down to the external aspects like a shared hairstyle, goatee, and buttoned-down sartorial sense. Cobb is a reluctant expat with a tragic past, and is given the chance to return to his children in the States by a wealthy Japanese businessman named Saito.

All of the crew’s efforts are focused towards manipulating the emotions of Robert Fischer, the petulant heir to a vast business empire. They must suspend his disbelief while appealing to his emotion, to the extent that they eventually bring him into the heist himself as an active participant.  Knowing all this, it becomes clear that Fischer is akin to the audience, albeit a particularly savvy one that’s seen it all before and stands resistant to cinema’s transcendent charms.

Visually speaking, Inception is arguably Nolan’s most audacious work, filled to the brim with wild, impossible imagery. The narrative affords Nolan the opportunity to explore and indulge in his fascination with the mechanics of time in a comprehensive and integral manner– befitting their place in a heist film, Cobb’s crew naturally races against a ticking clock, but they are uniquely positioned to alter the bounds of the race itself. Inception’s unique take on the mechanics of time is a singular signature of Nolan’s.

In a film loaded with symbolic imagery, the closing image of a top spinning on the table is arguably Inception’s most provoking one. The audience finds itself left on a sharply ambiguous final note, and an extremely frustrating one for those who prefer their movies to spell everything out for them. Is Cobb truly free of his dreams, or is he still trapped somewhere in his unconscious?

The question has inspired numerous armchair detectives to suss out an objective truth, most investigations point to Cobb’s wedding ring as his personal totem, and the film’s key signifier as to whether or not we are currently in a dream state. Cobb sports his ring in the dream sequences, but in his waking reality he appears without it.  When he lands in Los Angeles at the end of the film, he’s not wearing his ring.

Far from a final “gotcha” twist, the film’s ending arguably hits a precise note, cementing the film’s murky ambiguity between dreams and waking reality while challenging his audience with the notion that our own realities can be just as subjective.

In Interstellar, the world, simply put, must be saved– but this time, the responsibility falls not to superheroes but to scientists and mathematicians.  We begin in the back half of the 21st century, where the mounting effects of  pollution, industrialisation, and other byproducts of modern civilisation have ravaged the earth.

In America’s blight-plagued heartland, where a new Dust Bowl rages with increasing intensity, an ex-pilot turned corn farmer named Cooper is trying to eke out a hardscrabble existence with his two children and father-in-law. Cooper is a widower; cursed to wander the rest of his life without his mate.  Also like those characters, he’s whip-smart and resourceful; a natural-born leader with bottomless reserves of courage and a ferocious commitment to his family.

More than just a potential love interest for Cooper, Brand is a conduit through which Nolan presents one of Interstellar’s key ideas, the idea of “love” as a powerful, quantifiable cosmic concept.  In other words: the idea of “love” being a separate dimension unto itself that can transcend and influence time, space, and gravity.

Last but not least, Dunkirk was structured less as a conventional war film and more like a harrowing survival thriller, it recreates the evacuation of Allied forces from the eponymous coastal town in France as an awe-inspiring story of unfathomable courage and frenzied survival, despite the event itself serving as a tactical loss for the good guys.  This snatching of an emotional victory from the jaws of strategic defeat is precisely the sort of peculiar irony that attracted Nolan to the story.

Dunkirk takes a decentralised approach to its plot, trashing the idea of a singular protagonist in favour of enigmatic figureheads; fictional composites instead of historical accounts.  They have names, to be sure, but we as an audience don’t have the luxury of time to learn them when our very survival is at stake.  I say “our survival” because Nolan intends for these characters to simply serve as windows for the audience to immerse themselves in the harrowing sweep of history as it unfolds.  We never see beyond this limited, subjective perspective, we’re stuck with the Allied forces on the ground, forced to flee with them as chaos and destruction surrounding us.

Indeed, time, the device of the ticking clock, unifies the thematic whole of Dunkirk, placing the film as an exploratory apex within Nolan’s career.  Again, the story essentially functions as one large escape sequence, with the Allied forces racing against the clock from the encroaching German menace as they try to get off the beaches of Dunkirk and safely across the English Channel.

In a time where critics and audiences alike conflate movies with television and vice-versa as one indistinguishable medium, Nolan’s lifelong quest to preserve the sanctity of the movie-house and extoll its superiority to the home theatre has never been more urgent.  Nolan’s films are nothing less than a shot across the bow, a slap upside the head that compels us to remember what makes the communal moviegoer experience such a special one. 

Christopher Nolan is a great analyst of the “human soul” and the forces that drive men to go to the extremes of either horror or grandeur. He deals with male characters’ psychology is tremendous. These men are always complex, tortured, torn between good and evil, frantically mad or in a breathless search for justice. The subtleties and intricacies of their many layers can only be commended.

As soon as we turn to his female characters, we are quickly forced to admit that they are one-sided, one-dimensional, archetypal roles, with often no other purpose than to push the male hero in one direction or the other. They have no complexity or motivation. Sometimes, as in the case of Insomnia, they purely don’t exist at all.

In The Prestige, Angier and Borden’s murderous rivalry starts with Angier’s wife dying; in Memento, Guy Pearce’s character’s only motivation is to find his wife’s killer; in Insomnia, the original investigation begins with the murder of a teenage girl; in Inception, Dom Cobb is eaten alive by the memory of his wife’s suicide; in Dark Knight, Rachel’s death creates the crucial Two-Face character, etc.

The women who remain alive are blatantly excluded from Nolan’s favourite themes of obsession, search for purpose, crucial moral dilemmas and, of course, also the one he is so skilled at depicting, an epic duel between two men which often ends in death. Also, in Memento, many viewers in fact struggle to remember Natalie’s name or function in the film some time after seeing it. She is only a means to an end, showing the viewer how deeply Leonard’s condition affects him. In Insomnia and Dunkirk, in the manly struggle a woman appears to have no place.

Moreover, in Inception, the cast is almost entirely made of men. That team of extremely clever scientists, doctors and businessmen contains only one woman, Ellen Page, the clever-but-unattractive sidekick. She has no other purpose than to be beautiful and tragic. She is not strong-minded or particularly intelligent, she is a depressed wife and mother. Also, in Batman Begins, there are eight main characters and amongst them one woman, one woman who is essentially Bruce’s love interest and she is transformed into a mere element of a love triangle and the necessary victim halfway through the movie. Looks like Gotham City is a man’s, man’s, man’s world. Even Selina Kyle, she is not more than the sexy cat-woman in a tight leather suit using her charms to fool men.

The problem with Nolan’s women is that they are used as a means to glorify his men. Maybe one-dimensional female characters are the way for male characters to appear so well written. So all in all, Nolan loves killing off wives. But this feminist isn’t ready to write-off Nolan’s cinematic sensibilities just yet. It is said that behind every great man lies a woman, and this is certainly true in the case of a Nolan-directed flick.

However, to delight his audiences, Nolan adapted the script to his own liking, and transformed the character of Murphy, Interstellar’s  co-protagonist, 10 year old, into a daughter, not a son.

Let’s get back to Inception. The feminine threat of  it reveals itself as coming from a masculine force. This offers another chance to display gender as performed; Cobb’s subconscious contains a significant feminine presence, which he does not display but does at least possess. The public self can be hyper-masculine while the body still hosts multiple gender identities.

Next, this complicates the already mentioned understanding of the stabbing shot of Ariadne. The last note of interest is how this interacts with Deakin’s claims. To him, Mal’s character is the current iteration of Nolan’s “seeming myopic sense of female malignity”. The movie certainly introduces her that way, but over time her villainy becomes a product of Cobb, as an invention of either his mind or victim of his first attempt at inception. Male mistakes causing guilt in the male subconscious does not seem to be a cause for “female malignity” of any sort.

Right after that shot comes the scene where the camera accepts Ariadne’s visual perspective but not Cobb’s. Rather than let the camera return to male perspective, the movie rejects it. That conversation prompts Ariadne’s inclusion in the dream layers for the Inception mission, and she ultimately guides Cobb to a reunion with his children. 

Representation here means not the presence of women, which Hollywood already has, but the on-screen portrayal of femininity as something other than the object of male desire or subject of the male gaze. That is not to say that Mulvey and her advocates’ argument is simple, as much as to say that the actual shots of the film complicate the outlined narrative.

Nolan utilises the magic of film giving the audience only a taste of everything without foregoing too much, making the audience aware of the fake medium but revealing a genuine truth.  A cut to a Parisian Café allows the audience to believe our characters arrived at their destination logically and that they’re dining in a city familiar to us. Later, it is revealed to the audience the character’s actual method of transportation was a dream.  Nolan uses a cut to move us from scene to scene fully aware that the audience has learned to make logical assumptions about a feature’s continuity based on the exposure to previous films.  Nolan’s breaking of the audience’s assumptions heightens the viewer’s awareness of themselves as a viewer and intensifies their awareness of the art they are viewing. We learn we exit and enter the dream world throughout the film.  Nolan edits the audience into a dream.  He uses this technique to force the audience to decipher reality from the dream and exploit the story by capitalising on the medium itself.

Our filmmaker challenges the audience and the art of film, never clearly identifying the transition between reality and the dream.  Nolan pushes film, progressing and evolving the medium, and refining the art of the narrative, taking it beyond its traditions into the next stage of storytelling.

Inception, like Memento, is concerned with the mysterious sprawl inside the mind and memory, and like Following and Insomnia, its dream-heist plot sports some questionable ethics. But at its heart lies a man who is hounded by loss and guilt. He lets that guilt chase him into hell and jeopardise the lives of others, but ultimately he chooses the reality of his partners over the tempting fantasy of a dream world. In The Prestige, deception is the only beauty in a bleak world. In Inception, the hero sacrifices a fabricated love for a fuller reality with his family. Both films show that, post-Batman, Nolan’s response to evil has grown out of brainteasers and into a weighty moral maturity.

In addition, The Dark Knight resists moralising. It is not a mere allegory or clash of the ideological titans. There are archetypes here, ethical puzzles, downfall, and sacrifice; there is no doubt that Nolan has created a deeply moral film, forcing us to contend with evil in every scene. “Batman” is not a superhero but a hard-won vocation; Batman is Bruce’s vehicle for his social outrage.

For Nolan, the villains are not wrong to believe that people are corruptible. They are wrong to believe that people are past redemption. We have inherited Gotham, a once-great metropolis that we let go to the dogs. Harvey tells us that “you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain,” and we watch it become his story. In Nolan’s Gotham, humans fail. Bruce tries to enact his own human justice with a gun, but it was too small, too bleak. He needed to become more than a man to give us a justice worthy of the best in humans, and able to withstand the worst.

Finally, Nolan’s Inception is an implicit critique of ideology in a capitalist system. It exposes the ideological and mythological character of capitalism through its evocation of dreams and memory, the substrate of the unconscious that forms the core of individual subjectivity. Nolan’s fascination with time is also represented by his usage of montage and cross-cutting in pursuit of a subjective emotional experience and the building of dramatic intensity.

Nolan’s films explore and subvert our perception of time in pursuit of a greater, unified statement about the subjectivity and fragility of our individual realities, there is no single objective truth in his films, no matter how hard his characters search for it. Perhaps that’s why his protagonists are always so tortured or burdened with regret … they’ve devoted the entirety of themselves to the pursuit of something they ultimately can never attain.

Bibliography:

  1. G.S. Perno. (2014). Directors’ Trademarks: Christopher Nolan. Available: https://www.cinelinx.com/movie-news/movie-stuff/directors-trademarx-christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Dan Lewsey. (2017). Christopher Nolan: An Auteur, or Just Another Filmmaker?. Available: http://danlewsey.com/christophernolan/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. (2020). Application of Auteur Theory to Christopher Nolan. Available: https://www.ukessays.com/essays/film-studies/application-of-auteur-theory-to-christopher-nolan.php. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. Mary Wild. (2017). The Auteur Rises: Christopher Nolan and Dunkirk on Film. Available: https://www.citylit.ac.uk/blog/auteur-rises-christopher-nolan-and-dunkirk-film. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. Jacqui Griffin. (2017). A Quick Guide To Auteur Theory. Available: https://www.filminquiry.com/quick-guide-auteur-theory/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  6. Narrativeinart. (2011). Narrative In Art – Christopher Nolan. Available: https://narrativeinart.wordpress.com/nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  7. Cameron Beyl. (2020). Directors Series: Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk. Available: https://indiefilmhustle.com/dunkirk-christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  8. Cameron Beyl. (2017). Christopher Nolan: The Ultimate Guide to His Films and Directing Techniques. Available: https://indiefilmhustle.com/christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  9. Leon Saunders Calvert . (2010). How Christopher Nolan made Batman grow up. Available: https://offscreen.com/view/nolan_batman. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  10. AMANDA MARCOTTE. (2012). The Masked Morality of the Batman Trilogy. Available: https://prospect.org/culture/masked-morality-batman-trilogy/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  11. Lauren Wilford. (2012). BLEAKNESS AND RICHNESS: CHRISTOPHER NOLAN ON HUMAN NATURE. Available: https://theotherjournal.com/2012/04/17/bleakness-and-richness-christopher-nolan-on-human-nature/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  12. Andrew Kania. (2014). THE TWISTED FEMMES FATALES OF CHRISTOPHER NOLAN. Available: https://aestheticsforbirds.com/2014/06/01/the-twisted-femmes-fatales-of-christopher-nolan-by-andrew-kania/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  13. Anna Kessler. (2012). It’s a man’s man’s man’s world… The cinema of Christopher Nolan. Available: https://thefword.org.uk/2012/10/films_of_christopher_nolan/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  14. David Foster Wallace. (2016). Inception, Gender Politics, and Perspective: Answering the Masculine Malaise. Available: https://sites.williams.edu/engl-117-fall16/uncategorized/inception-gender-politics-and-perspective-answering-the-masculine-malaise/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  15. ANNA KLASSEN. (2014). Christopher Nolan’s Feminist ‘Interstellar’ Isn’t His First Pro-Women Film. Available: https://www.bustle.com/articles/46389-christopher-nolans-feminist-interstellar-isnt-his-first-pro-women-film. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  16. Brent Cowley, B.A. B.S.. (2017). THE PSYCHOLOGY OF A DARK KNIGHT. In: “REALITY” WHILE DREAMING IN A LABYRINTH: CHRISTOPER NOLAN AS REALIST AUTEUR. digital.library.unt.edu: . 53-57.

The Joker: heinous villain or unreliable narrator ; or both!

One of the important and rather interesting aspects of Joker is Arthur’s position of an unreliable narrator. He invents an entire relationship with a female character in the film, which makes the question of his paternity that arises later even more interesting, with questions around whether his mother did the same, based on the reaction from the Waynes when he attempts to investigate. Arthur’s lack of reliability also seems to suit the typical murky origins of the Joker character, as having appeared out of nowhere and not really having a clear “origin” compared to the other characters in the DC universe.

A big part of the Joker’s appeal is that, as an agent of chaos, he’s defined by indefinability. In a genre that prizes origin stories as key building blocks in its storytelling, the Joker’s refusal to be pinned down to any one starting point is unique. 

In the beginning of the film, we see Phoenix’s Arthur Fleck, a misunderstood weirdo, pushed to the very edge of sanity until, with a smile and some face paint, he finally steps over it. Simple and definitive. 

It’s all a little… off. Fitting for a character who we know always lies, and if this crucial trait is adhered to in the film, that makes Arthur an unreliable narrator. It could well be that we’re not necessarily watching the Joker, but a Joker. If that clown-faced mob is anything to go by, he’s already inspiring copycats. Again, it’s the “one bad day” rationale. Anyone can become the Joker, a Joker, if they’re given enough of a push. 

My main debate about Joker is the unreliability of its narrative. I had to watch the film twice to complete my review about it. There is no doubt that the film is great and the performance of Joaquin Phoenix was outstanding that made him deserve the Oscar. However, I was questioning myself “Did Arthur need help and understanding due to his mental problems?”; “Is he innocent and the bad community around him pushed him to become the Joker?”; “What is right and what is wrong?”. Is there any absolute truthful answer? There is no absolute truth!


In my opinion, everything that happened in the film may have happened to Arthur but not in the same way that the film shows us. He is delusional  and during the film we, the audience, cannot know when things are really happening or when they are only merely a figment of Arthur’s imagination. We understand this when we see him in the restaurant with Sophie but she is not there.

Also, in the hospital when we realise that he is alone with his mother and she never went there. All the flashbacks for those scenes were crucial to deliver that message. Although we would understand when Sophie tells him to leave, denying their relationship the layout of the plot should be like this to make us understand clearly that these things happened but not as we have seen them in the beginning.

Audience sees what Arthur wanted the things to look like. And this is the key of the film narrative. Everything that happened wasn’t in relation with Arthur but in his illusion, it happened for his own benefit. For that reason, the duplication is very obvious in the plot and in Arthur’s personality. It started to appear when he got the gun from his co-worker Randall. In the scene, we see Randall persuading Arthur to take the gun for protection and he acts like he cares about him and says “You are my boy”, as they are close friends. Then, in the next scene, when Arthur speaks to the manager, he has been told that no one from his colleagues like him and they think that he is “ a freak”. The joker emphasises this later after he kills Randall and leaves Gary unharmed because he is the only one who was treating him well. So, who is lying? Randall or the manager? Or It’s just an unbelievable narrative?

Randall tells the police that Arthur bought the gun himself, and Arthur is fired after the gun falls out of his pocket while entertaining at a children’s hospital. In fact, Arthur bothered Randall for weeks to get the gun from him. All the conversation between them when he got it was imagined by Arthur that creates a feeling of love and pertinence. This makes him irresponsible for having the gun! The proof that the conversation was an illusion is that Arthur never had such a kind conversation like that. Even in the beginning of the film, we have seen an imagined conversation between him and Murray that is kind and creates a feeling of love and pertinence in Arthur’s heart. Once the conversation is done with Randall, they all laugh at a joke and Arthur stops laughing at the corner so do they, which is up-normal. In real life, nobody weirdly laughs like this. His illusion ends when he meets the manager and hears the truth.

This is not the only situation that is a figment of Arthur’s imagination. In the subway, he created the fight in his mind and the businessmen never beated him but he images that to give himself an excuse for that murder. Later, in Murray’s show he confesses to that murder and explains that the only reason for doing it is that they are “awful” and he doesn’t mention the self-defending excuse. Maybe the only bad thing that they did is singing the clown’s song to insult him. After the murder, the mayoral candidate Thomas Wayne appears on TV and calls those envious of more successful people “clowns.” Is it possible for a successful businessman and genius politician to give such a speech. Most people in Gotham are poor. So, he wouldn’t lose a wide range of proponents and describes them by “clowns”. It’s just the imagination of Arthur that made us see it like this. He wants to convince himself that he can influence the people and start a huge revolution.

The demonstrations were already started in the beginning because of the waste crisis as we hear on the radio, and have nothing to do with Arthur at all.  Moreover, all people in Gotham are shown wearing the same mask during the film, which is not possible. This is the mask that Arthur wears in his job and is hung on his mirror, in the early scenes. He is not the only clown in the city and it’s impossible that they have only one design for the clown masks. This means that all of this is just part of his illusion that connects what is happening with his inner changes. Then, at the backstage of the show, the Joker, in full make up, is asked by Murray if the clown make up is related to the demonstrations, and he denies. If the oppositions were clowns they wouldn’t let the Joker be in the show with his make up. Nobody wears ISIS’s flag because they like black colour!

After the Joker murders Murray and is arrested while riots break out across Gotham, an accident happens and Arthur has been rescued out of the car. The way that he was carried was very professional and looks like trained medical crew are doing it. Of course he has never been carried by that huge group of people, with the same clown mask, to celebrate him as a hero then put him in Arkham. Yes it was an accident, but then, he was moved to Arkham by an ambulance and none of that imagined scene really happened.

In conclusion, Joker is not a story of a rejected person who suffers from a mental disorder. It’s a development of a villain who bought a gun and used it in the first opportunity that he faced. All that illusion and imagined scenes are made by him to make himself live the feeling of being loved and accepted. This is actually all he wants but unfortunately he couldn’t reach it. All the changes and development in his character is true and the growth of his confidence is true. Finally, in the end, he could control his laugh after it was uncontrollable and caused him many problems all over the film.

Bibliography:

  1. (2020). The art of the unreliable narrator in Joke. Available: https://the-artifice.com/the-art-of-the-unreliable-narrator-in-joker/. Last accessed 01/06/20.
  2. HANNAH COLLINS. (2019). The Joker Might Be An Origin Story, But Not THE Joker Origin Story. Available: https://www.cbr.com/joker-movie-origin-not-definitive/. Last accessed 01/06/20.

Scopophilic Narratives and Complicit Acts of Voyeurism -in Blue Velvet film-

In the early 1970s, French, American and British movie theorists began applying psychoanalysis to film in an attempt to discuss the spectator-screen relationship. It’s important because “Look” is a term that is criticised with identification about characteristics, space and what we see on screen; and at the end it is nearly everything about effectiveness of a film on a spectator. We should draw an analogy of the screen with the mirror as a way of talking about spectator positioning and the voyeuristic aspect of film viewing whereby the spectator is identified with the gaze. Freud defines scopophilia as the deepest taste of sight. According to him, the pleasure of looking is a basic instinct, and we can also search the roots of fetishism around these subjects. For someones, voyeurism term is counted as fetishism also.

Voyeurism is the sexual interest in or practice of spying on people engaged in intimate behaviours, such as undressing, sexual activity, or other actions usually considered to be of a private nature. Even if all we watch on the screen is fiction, we spectate someone’s life without their conscious and permission,consciously. There are many arguments about voyeurism in cinema, but one of the most important examples is Alfred Hitchcock’s Rear Window movie. Blue Velvet is also a great example, which will be used in this report. In this film, there are some kinds of complexes that can be argued in the subject of voyeurism.

The term voyeurism describes what are in fact two phenomena, different though not always easily distinguishable, which is called covert and collusive. ‘Covert voyeurism’, ‘is a narcissistic form of penetrative aggression directly related to Primal Scene fantasies and it involves gratification through the watching of objects who are themselves unaware of being watched […]. Collusive voyeurism on the other hand involves the experience of pleasure through the activity of watching objects who are well aware that they are being watched […]. This is a more sophisticated form of perversion because it implies some recognition that others are not just extensions of one’s own self, but real persons responding to the voyeuristic activities of the subject and potentially getting themselves exhibitionistic satisfaction from being looked at’.

Sexual perversions refer to a variety of fantasies – from fetishism to necrophilia, to the two-sided coins of voyeurism/exhibitionism and sado/masochism – fantasies sometimes played out in actual activities involving relationships with other people, but mostly relegated to the dark corners of one’s unconscious mind.

Blue Velvet, written and directed by Lynch in 1986, is a masterful work providing material sufficiently intense to deeply engage the audience, spectators, both visually and emotionally, but so artfully created as to allow them to immerse themselves in this material without becoming excessively disturbed by it. He mixes classical Hollywood narrative structure with postmodernist auteur understanding in the base of the movie.

The film similarly presents the innocence of domesticity as nothing but a naïve folly, the antithesis of the world’s strangeness. It  suggests that order is unattainable in the modern world. We must keep watch over one another because while our neighbours run amok, authority is unreliable at best.

Blue Velvet, as Lynch describes, is a “story of love and mystery.” In order to experience this story of love and mystery, Lynch invites the viewer to enter into a hermetic space as both detective and voyeur. Lynch creates a world that is at once familiar and strange; it is a world governed by opposites, where surface and depth, good and evil coexists simultaneously. In the film, opposites function to delimit a certain psychological space, one that is momentarily available to the viewer through identification with the male protagonist. Perhaps one of the most unique aspects of Lynch’s film-making is his ability to translate psychological and dream space into a cinematic experience. Also, one of the most compelling aspects of Lynch’s style is his ability to make that which is familiar, strange.

With Sandy’s ambivalent collusion Jeffrey intrudes into Dorothy’s private space and personal life. Hidden inside a closet in her apartment, he witnesses Dorothy being verbally and sexually abused by criminal boss and psychopathic supremo Frank Booth who, having kidnapped her son and husband, uses his perverse powers to control her. Discovered by Frank, Jeffrey has then to bravely engage in some frightening confrontations with him. To further complicate matters, Jeffrey becomes erotically involved with Dorothy and romantically with Sandy, until the narrative gets resolved into a deliberately unconvincing ‘happy ending’.


“We all have at least two sides. The world we live in is a world of opposites. And the trick is to reconcile those opposing things. I’ve always liked both sides. In order to appreciate one you have to know the other. The more darkness you can gather up, the more light you can see too.”

The notion of surface and depth, order and chaos, come into play according to a Freudian logic of the unconscious. Lynch, himself, has acknowledged his aesthetic interest in extreme differences: “Everybody’s got many threads of good and evil running through them”. This contrast between light and dark, surface and depth is treated quite literally in the film. The formal contrasts between colours contribute to the film’s dream-like atmosphere. For instance, the supersaturated brightness of the red tulips and yellow daffodils, set against the white picket fence make the blackness of night seem thicker and more impervious. 

Moreover, the characters articulate psychological states of love and hate through evocation of light and dark. Sandy, for instance, speaks of a dream in which thousands of robins bring forth light and love to illuminate the darkness of the world. By contrast, Frank Booth finds comfort in and feeds off of the absence of light. He remarks at several points in the film, “now it’s dark,” as if to communicate his psychological comfort and familiarity with the unconscious.

One of the most overt plays with opposites arises from Lynch’s noir-inspired use of women in the film. Respectively, Sandy and Dorothy Vallens function as opposite poles by which Jeffrey gauges his own mental states. He associates with Sandy most often during the day, communicating with her his rational plans and hypotheses about the mystery he is involved in. Dorothy, by contrast, is associated with the irrational, and exists as a site for Jeffrey to gain knowledge of his own unconscious desires and perversions. While the two women function as counterpoints in the film, Michael Chion suggests that they in fact incarnate two sides of one figure, “each side endlessly leading to the other as in a mobius strip.”

While Jeffrey tries to help Dorothy, he turns into a man who is dragged into Dorothy’s desire to take advantage of her womanhood and approaches her with violence and instinct. This can also be explained by the fact that the disturbing elements of human beings are brought to the forefront through Lynch’s characters. Then, Jeffrey became a participant in voyeurism and eventually in sadomasochistic behaviour and in actions that appeared and he could not prevent.This also expresses the extreme desires that Jeffrey’s subconscious and social conventions suppress. Even Sandy’s suppression of himself in line with these rules leads Jeffrey to create a character like Dorothy under his consciousness. Frank and Jeffrey are also in the fight for sexual power. The dangerous man, Frank Booth, is an impotent, sadistic, terrible, cruel man with an Oedipus complex. He is trying to alleviate the disgust that he feels himself, by harming people and to enjoying it. At the same time, he has fetishistic impulse. He has a fetish in Dorothy’s blue velvet robe. When he touches it or takes it in his mouth, he has sexual satisfaction.His death was due to Dorothy and her perverted connection with him, as well as his obsession with revenge on Jeffrey and the cops who followed him. Jeffrey shot him down and the Oedipus complex process was completed.

By way of identifying with Jeffrey as protagonist, the viewer initially engages the film’s mystery in the role of detective. Gradually, the invitations to a voyeuristic gaze position the viewer more as a pervert. Sandy playfully poses the question to Jeffrey: “I don’t know if you are a detective or a pervert,” inciting the viewer to reflect, as well, on his own motivations and desires to know and to see. As Lynch readily remarks, “Film is really voyeurism…we want to see secret things, we really want to see them.” The pinnacle scene in which the film indulges this scopophilic desire occurs when Jeffrey witnesses the “primal scene” between Frank and Dorothy. As cinematographer Fred Elmes recalls, the camera’s point of view was kept in line with that of Jeffrey’s from his location in the closet.. We never shot anything that he couldn’t actually see from the closet.

As Chion notes, the performance appears contrived so as to elicit the greatest amount of pleasure for Jeffrey the voyeur. What is unusual about this scene is its theatricality. One wonders whether the characters do not enter, speak, move and behave solely to please the voyeur knowing full well they are giving him a show.

Indeed, not only do Dorothy and Frank give Jeffrey a good show, they do so for the cinematographer who, shrouded in the darkness of the theatre, sits in his own closet of sorts. I suggest that Lynch fully understands narrative cinema’s conventions of viewing, making Blue Velvet a particularly self-conscious film. He plays with these conventions not only through exaggeration, but also through an interruption of sorts. Upon Dorothy’s discovery of Jeffrey, she pulls him out of the spectator’s role and forces him “to exhibit himself, as on a stage.” This unusual turn of events no doubt makes the spectator nervous, particularly as Dorothy brandishes her knife threatening castration. Despite the intense sexual and violent energies Lynch brings up in this scene, there is a certain humour in witnessing such a literal enactment of Freudian clichés. And it is the viewer’s familiarity with these cinematic routines that gives the film a pleasure surpassing that of mere scopophilia. The mystery and beauty of the mind, for Lynch, is momentarily graspable through film as a language of the subconscious. 

Jeffrey’s attempt to solve a mystery is then also a search for his own identity and masculinity. Jeffrey’s watching Dorothy being forced into a ritualised sexual encounter with Frank is an instance of collusive voyeurism. Dorothy is well aware of Jeffrey’s presence in the closet, and Jeffrey is well aware that she is well aware of it; but it is also an example of covert scopophilia insofar as Frank does not know of Jeffrey’s hidden presence in the room. Excited and horrified in equal measure, like a child exposed to the primal scene in the parental bedroom, Jeffrey watches on, and we with him as the fixed camera’s position invites us to identify with him. It could be argued that both Jeffrey and Dorothy were forced to create such a voyeuristic/exhibitionistic scenario, rather than having voluntarily constructed it for their own sexual pleasure.

It would be easy to describe Dorothy as Frank’s sex slave as we learn that he can control her by holding her husband and son hostage. We watch him violently abusing Dorothy, his face distorted in a grotesque sneer and covered by a mask through which he breathes amylnitrate, a drug inducing a state of euphoria and visual hallucinations. But his sadistic and drug fuelled sexuality is complementary to Dorothy’s masochistic association of pleasure with pain; while Frank is raping her, Lynch’s camera closes up on the almost ecstatic expression on her face. Soon after this scene we watch Dorothy seducing Jeffrey and begging him to: ‘Hit me, hit me, HIT ME!’. Presumably, she could only reach orgasm, for reasons likely to originate from some childhood traumatic experience, when feeling hurt and humiliated. Jeffrey, reluctant at first and guilty afterwards, complies with her request, realising perhaps that ‘the condition for his sexual initiation entails his acceptance of his sadistic impulses’ .

Often going unnoticed to others, the power of such persecutory fantasies can dramatically create for those affected by them the terrifying experience of living in hell. This may even apply to the world inhabited by Frank himself, a paranoid, psychotic inner universe which he can only survive by forcibly projecting it onto others. One aspect of it is his incapacity to think in other than concrete terms; for instance, he can only understand in such terms the metaphorical meaning of the ‘blue velvet’ in Dorothy’s signature song. We see him fetishistically caressing a piece of blue velvet material when listening to her singing in the Slow Club, placing the blue velvet belt of her dressing gown in her and his own mouth while raping her, and having pushed yet another blue velvet cloth in the mouth of her murdered husband, we then discover, whose left ear had been cut off. Shot by Jeffrey, Frank dies holding Dorothy’s dressing gown across his arm.

In this film, Dorothy is a factor in Frank’s Oedipus complex and is described as mum, at the same time being mum of a son, in the movie. There is sadomasochistic sexuality between Frank and Dorothy. Frank, who has mental disorders, is aware of his own illness and reflects his anger about himself and his diversity outwardly, and especially to Dorothy as violence. She must have had this violence for a long time. Thus, the violence she sees has now become an element that satisfies her in a masochistically sexual way. Dorothy then notices that she is being watched by a voyeurs man. After seeing Jeffrey, she picks up the knife and tells him to take off his clothes. She reflects the violence to Jeffrey that she learned from Frank, and sadistic sexual events come to the forefront. Even if she is in a hard condition like beaten and tortured, then left as naked, she was trying to charm Jeffrey at Sandy’s home in front of her.Furthermore, in the ending part, we see that she comes to Jeffrey’s house as naked and tortured. And she does not care being watched by Mike and his friends and also other neighbours. When we come to Frank, he gives lots of examples in the movie about how much he hates being spectated.

The Oedipus Complex, according to psychoanalytic theory, consists of a boy’s ownership of his mother, the elimination of a parent in his same sexuality, feelings, thoughts and nudibranchs. According to Freud, a child’s first love is the parent who has the opposite gender of her/him. The boy hesitates from the father, a power authority at home, and sees him as a competitor.  In this movie, Frank represents the oedipal-father. He could not get out of the Oedipus complex. At the end of the movie, Jeffrey killed Frank and the Oedipus tragedy becomes real. Also regulation is settled to normal one with Dorothy embracing her real son. Primary Scene is the moment when a child sees his/her mother and father through sexual intercourse. It can not be remembered but it is suppressed. If the child remembers seeing this moment, this is called a secondary scene. From here we can figure out what Jeffrey witnessed in a primary scene. According to that Jeffrey becomes the baby in the Oedipal complex triangle here.

Some psychoanalytic authors who have written about this film focus on Jeffrey’s attempts to deal with his as-yet unresolved Oedipal issues. When Sandy asks Jeffrey, “Are you a pervert or a detective?”, it is a rhetorical question, for we can see that the detective’s search will embody a perverse solution’. Jeffrey is both a detective and a pervert, insofar as all detectives are, so to speak, also perverts. Here, then, Sandy’s question would relate not just to Jeffrey, but also to her own father who had chosen the detection of crimes as his professional activity. And it would relate to us, curious viewers of Blue Velvet …

As both Jeffrey and Sandy state more than once: ‘It’s a strange world, isn’t it?’

Finally, the movie has a happy ending like almost all Hollywood films. In comparison to other waves of cinema that the world has been seen before, its low budget is the same with nearly every cinematic wave in order to try something new, speaking something unspoken and directed by an alien-head to this world. 

Lynch got involved in the story of Blue Velvet, and so taken by his need to tell it in the visual language so distinctively his own, that he was not too bothered about its reception. Sekoff critically suggests that ‘Blue Velvet enters popular culture as another fetish, a commodity fetish that allows the purchase of an experience of the “dark side” of life’. Lynch is a visionary, intuitive rather than intellectual filmmaker. As a result, his story-telling style is often free associative and requires from us viewers a complementary attitude of free-floating attention, or suspended disbelief, analogous to that familiar to those of us sitting behind an analytic couch.

Bibliography:

  1. Andrea Sabbadini. (2018). ‘It’s a strange world, isn’t it?’ A voyeuristic lens on David Lynch’s Blue Velvet. Available: https://calibanrlp.com/en/its-a-strange-world-isnt-it-a-voyeuristic-lens-on-david-lynchs-blue-velvet/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Anne Dunn, Rosemary Huisman, Helen Fulton, Julian Murphet. (2005). Scopophilia. In: Anne Dunn, Rosemary Huisman, Julian Murphet, Helen Fulton Narrative and Media. Google Books: Cambridge University Press. 88-89.
  3. Kübra Nisanoğlu. PSYCHOANALYSIS, VOYEURISM, FETISHISM AND FEMINIST THEORY: BLUEVELVET CASE BY DAVID LYNCH. Available: https://www.academia.edu/41386266/PSYCHOANALYSIS_VOYEURISM_FETISHISM_AND_FEMINIST_THEORY_BLUE_VELVET_CASE. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. Stephanie Lam. (2009). David Lynch’s Blue Velvet The Use of Binary Oppositions and Space. Available: https://offscreen.com/view/lynch_blue_velvet. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. TOM WATCHORN. (2016). How Blue Velvet reflects the voyeuristic gaze of Rear Window. Available: https://lwlies.com/articles/blue-velvet-rear-window-voyeurism/. Last accessed 01/04/20.

Postmodernism – in Blade Runner film –

Postmodernism is defined as defiance and as a form of refusal to conform to the ideas and theories of the modernist approach in films. It stands to revolt against the traditions and views and cultures offered by modernist theories and aims to replace the existent innovation with a fresh new one that is more revolutionary and refined and an extraordinary version of the old; bolder and larger than it is, on par with the cutting edge.

The term “postmodernism” expresses something quite  peculiar about , but also something that is rather  particular to  the nan-cial stage of capitalism. In a sense, nance helps to obliterate the future. Today, we live in a perpetual present that makes us increasingly cynical of the very possibility of a better world.  This is a feature that ties  nance to the culture of postmodernism, the evisceration of history, and the “specialisation” of time, overlapping with the culture of digital and instant access.  Take  contemporary  online  video  streaming  services  like Netflix or Youtube, for instance. To be more precise, postmodernism is a theory  of culture consisting of five elements. It approaches culture and history through a critique of meta-narratives such as Marxism and psychoanalysis; it focuses on cultural representations in and across media; its attention to new media draws out some of the complications of our experiences of reality; it challenges traditional conceptions of subjectivity and identity, particularly those that tie human identity and human  nature to  the body and  to self – consciousness; and  it  emphasises pluralism in terms of race, gender, sexuality, and class.

Postmodernism in the fields of Cinema describes as an expression of Arts, and in Films, it may be perceived in various styles comprising the manner of twisting the mindset of not only the actor portraying a certain character in a particular film. It may also affect the judgement and reasoning of a moviegoer. Toying with their capacity to weigh down and identify the difference between the real truth from the fabricated truth and from what is only just an “acting” from what is already real life. Postmodernism in films approach may tend to bend a “lie” and make it appear as though it is an out-crying truth, thus making everyone believe and anchor on that crooked truth that is only offered by a film.

With its attention to pluralism, postmodern theory works to dissolve the boundary between high art and popular culture. Instead of seeing popular culture as simply a tool for the reproduction of dominant ideology, postmodernism maintains a pluralistic focus in suggesting that popular culture should be taken seriously as  a matter of legitimate cultural expression and pleasure.

Through its critique  of  the  media,  postmodern  theory  suggests  that  our experiences of reality are always  preceded  by models and representations, implying, therefore, that our experiences of reality are all a matter of appearance, simulation, and simulacra (or, a copy without an original). There is for postmodernism, in other words, no deeper reality behind the representation; all of reality is a mere matter of mediated simulation. With a focus on issues of representation and surfaces, postmodern cultural objects and texts often comprise references to the past and are filled with quotations of past cultural styles and stereotypes. However, these are references to a  simulated  past, or simulations of cultural stereotypes from the past. This is one of the reasons why history gures into debates about postmodernism, and disputes persist as to whether these references are intended to be ironic, or if they result in the depoliticization of the past and, consequently, the present.

Some theorists of  postmodernism argue that parody and irony are used in postmodern texts to reference and criticise the past, and in this way, postmodernism is highly political; others suggest that  postmodern representations cite historical references to  the past, but  without acknowledging their source, a  practice called pastiche. The discussion of postmodernism and Blade Runner will involve a consideration of questions of identity and history, of the role of simulacra and simulation, and of the relationship between postmodernism, architecture, and post industrialism.

By taking a  popular film like Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner as an example to analyse, this report will show how postmodernism and postmodern theory works in films. Since the postmodern critique of meta-narratives problematizes the subject’s understanding of herself in time and space, cognitive mapping is an attempt to return her to some  type  of  meaningful, yet politically soluble position. In fact, the film is significant not only because it exemplifies the postmodern but also because it can be seen as a marker of the transition from modernity to post-modernity.

In the film Blade Runner directed by Ridley Scott, the film embodies many important characters’ aspects of the postmodern cultural period. The film is mostly about what it means to be human in a controlled technological advanced world, and the struggle between humans and replicants. Which are machines that are so much like humans you can’t tell them apart, but it has a deeper meaning of a world in the future and you can see this with the many symbols laid out in the film. In the film, it always rains and the sun never shines and the streets are narrow and filthy. The film revisits the past, mimics it and holds it up to ridicule. The freedom that humans give up so easily to machines so willing is the actual danger in the modern society which leads to a post-modern.

The film is populated by eclectic crowds of faceless people, Oriental merchants, punks, Hari Krishnas. Even the language is pastiche: “city speech” is a “mishmash of Japanese, Spanish, German, what have you.” The city is a large market; an intrigue of underground networks pervades all relations. The explosive Orient dominates, the Orient of yesterday incorporating the Orient of today. Overlooking the city is the “Japanese simulacrum,” the huge advertisement which alternates between a seductive Japanese face and a Coca Cola sign. In the postindustrial city the explosion of urbanisation, melting the futuristic high- tech look into an intercultural scenario, recreates the third world inside the first.

The postmodern visual of Blade Runner is the result of recycling and the system only works if there is waste produced. The disconnected temporality of the replicants and the pastiche city are all an effect of a postmodern, post-industrial condition, wearing out, waste. A postmodern position exposes such logic, producing a visual of recycling. Costumes also are designed according to this logic. There is even the increased speed of development and process produces the diminishing of distances. Things cease to function and life is over even if it has not ended. The post-industrial city is a city of ruins.

It is in the architectural layout of Blade Runner that pastiche is most dramatically visible and where the connection of postmodernism to post industrialism is evident. The city of Blade Runner is not the ultramodern, but the postmodern city. It is not an orderly layout of skyscrapers and ultra comfortable, hyper mechanised interiors. Rather, it creates an aesthetic of decay, exposing the dark side of technology.

Post-modernity is on its way to the future, but then seeks shelter in the past; Blade Runner has many boundaries between past and present. The audience is told the film is set in the future in 2019, but there still happens to be a lot of evidence of the past such as; the eighties clothes and haircuts, the language and the technology looks extremely outdated. The reasons why there is evidence of the past are that Blade Runner is a film based in the future that is afraid of the future. Films that are portrayed like this usually are made to warn people about the dangers around the corner. In postmodern films they present the unpresentable and what was formerly thought of as unsuitable.

In addition, hyper-reality, a condition in which “reality” has been replaced. It is presented in the film’s opening. It, in a very recognisable scenery, backs up the inclusion of futuristic elements creating a reality we can easily believe. Film noir meets science fiction dark lighting despite the presence of bright lights and neon signs, the majority of the film is covered in shadows that helps to create a pessimistic atmosphere, which is a convention of film noir titles.

Furthermore, the film’s characters are questionable as Deckard, the protagonist, is presented as the hero of the story, he questions his orders to kill the replicants but still carries them out, causing us to question whether or not he’s really a good guy. Roy, the antagonist, is presented as the stereotypical bad guy, and yet the appropriateness of his actions are called into question when it’s revealed he’s just trying to keep him and his friends alive. Also, Rachael, the love interest of Tyrell’s latest experiment, doesn’t find out she is a replicant until the plot of the movie takes place. At this point, Deckard is tasked to kill her, and we are forced to ask whether or not she deserves to live.

J.F. Sebastian is twenty-five years old, but his skin is wrinkled and decrepit. His internal process and time are accelerated, and he is wearing out. “Accelerated decrepitude” is how the replicant Pris describes his condition, noting that he and the replicants have something in common. What Pris does not say is that the city suffers from it as well. The psychopathology of J.F. Sebastian, the replicants, and the city is the psychopathology of the everyday postindustrial condition. The increased speed of development and process produces the diminishing of distances, of the space in between, of distinction. Time and tempo are reduced to a climax., after which there is retirement.

Moreover, Blade Runner presents a manifestation of the schizophrenic condition, in the sense that Lacan gives this term. The schizophrenic condition is characterised by the inability to experience the persistence of the “I” over time. There is neither past nor future at the two poles of that which thus becomes a perpetual present. 

The schizophrenic temporality of the replicants is a resistance to enter the social order, to function according to its modes. Their killing constitutes a state murder. It is called “retirement,” a word which connotes exclusion from the productive and active social order. The replicants search for their origins. They want to know who “conceived them, and they investigate their identity and the link to their makers. The itinerary is that of an Oedipal journey. To survive for a time, the android has to accept the fact of sexual difference, the sexual identity which the entry into language requires.

The film posits questions of identity, identification, and history in postmodernism. The text’s insistence on photography. on the eye, is suggestive of the problematic of the “I” over time. Photography, ”the impossible science of the unique being,” is the suppressed trace of history, the lost dream of continuity. Photography is memory. The status of memory has changed. In a postmodern age, memories are no longer Proustian madeleines, but photographs. The past has become a collection of photographic, filmic, or televisual images. We, like the replicants, are put in the position of reclaiming a history by means of its reproduction.

The film works inter-textually and allegorically at the level of its interpretation, so that what it does in terms of cognitive mapping is provide some thematic ground to concretize postmodern conceptions of subjectivity and history. For instance, the role of photographs in the film. Photographs are both markers of real history for both Rachael and Leon. Thematically, the film remarks upon the postmodern view of history, of the fact that history always comes to us in representational form, and that it gets lost without a real referent.

In her visit to Deckard, Rachel produces her memories in response to his photographs. She attempts to look like the woman in his old photograph, and plays the piano to recapture a memory, an atmosphere. Leon’s previously kept pictures serve no apparent purpose other than the documentation of the replicant’s existence in history. Deckard understands this motivation when he finds the photos. “I don’t know why replicants would collect photos. Maybe they were like Rachel, they needed memories.” Photographs assert the referent, its reality, in that they assert its existence at that (past) moment when the person, the thing, was there in front of the camera. If a replicant is in a photograph, he or she is thus real.

Audience interpretation of human, or replicant? constantly left ambiguous throughout the film, the way it portrays replicants as emotional and humans as cold brings up the idea that Deckard himself may be a replicant. Harrison Ford played him as human, but Ridley Scott left it deliberately vague. The film’s ending is left deliberately ambiguous in the latest release of the film allows the audience to interpret the events their own way.

Blade Runner has one main message that the future is hopeless. It marks a new age by showing its own end. It is shown as industrial and dark, the raining weather and no sunshine which create a moody atmosphere. Technology has progressed so rapidly but, still manages to lack the new look. The postmodernism of this film is displayed throughout this whole film. It represents the chaos of what happens when the people reject the modern period. It embodies the present pushing forward to the future as well as holding on to the past to create post-industrialism. The more technology we gain and control always has a bad side for everything.

In conclusion, as Matthew emphasised, the film escapes parody and reminds that the difference between parody and pastiche is still central to debates about postmodernism by helping to build up cyberpunk as a uniquely postmodern genre. So, although the film is postmodern in its nostalgic references to stereotypes of past genres, and it exemplifies pastiche in its mode of subtracting the history of these genres, by helping to produce Cyberpunk as a genre, Blade Runner, we might say, has created history.

Bibliography:

  1. Dale Luck. (2012). Blade Runner – Postmodernism. Available: https://pt.slideshare.net/DaleLuck/blade-runner-postmodernism/4. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Essay in Film Studies. (2018). A Metaphor Of Postmodernism In Blade Runner. Available: https://www.ukessays.com/essays/film-studies/a-metaphor-of-postmodernism-in-blade-runner-film-studies-essay.php. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. GIULIANA BRUNO. Ramble City: Postmodernism and Blade Runner. Available: https://web.stanford.edu/dept/HPS/Bruno/bladerunner.html#:~:text=The%20postmodern%20aesthetic%20of%20Blade,condition%3A%20wearing%20out%2C%20waste.. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. Matthew Flisfeder. (2017). ‘Quite an experience’, Blade Runner, Marxism and Postmodernity. Available: https://www.rs21.org.uk/2017/10/13/revolutionary-reflections-quite-an-experience-blade-runner-marxism-and-postmodernity/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. Matthew Flisfeder. (2017). From postmodernism to capitalist realism . In: Todd McGowan Postmodern Theory and Blade Runner. Google Books: Bloomsbury. 15-18.
  6. (2014). Postmodernism in Films. Available: http://filmtheory.org/postmodernism-in-films/. Last accessed 01/06/19.
  7. (2016). POSTMODERN THEORIES: BRICOLAGE AND INTERTEXTUALITY… Available: http://postmodernism-a2media.blogspot.com/2016/01/postmodern-theories-bricolage-and.html. Last accessed 01/06/19.
  8. (2014). Parody and pastiche – Postmodernism. Available: https://www.slideshare.net/missgillies/parody-and-pastiche. Last accessed 01/06/19.

Ideological Representation in ‘Apocalypse Now’

This report will comment on the explicit or implicit ideological and moral basis for the film Apocalypse Now, and on how its stance is conveyed through narrative, characterisation and, or mise-en-scene.

To many Americans, the Vietnam war was an American extravaganza, staged in Vietnam. To concede that it was a civil war is to relegate America to a supporting role in someone else’s drama. But that is exactly what it was, someone else’s drama. In spite of all the billions spent by the US, the Vietnam war was essentially a Vietnamese affair. The stakes were simply much higher for them.

This film is original in its moral and ethical emphases, and its portrayal of the results of war; it contains the action demanded by cinema audiences, but also emphasises its corresponding brutality and suffering. Films such as Coppola’s Apocalypse Now are not only nonconformist in their rejection of government propaganda and approved ethical views, but also seek to question the psyche of western civilisation, the inherited belief, from the Christian era to imperialism, that European society not only controls the balance of world power, but is a model for other, inferior non-European peoples. Not only does the film constitute a critique of the Vietnam war but also bring into question the very ideological fabric of an aggressive, expansive and socially regimented post-war America.

Apocalypse Now is based upon Joseph Conrad’s novel, Heart of Darkness, in which Marlow, captain of a continental trading vessel working in the African Congo, describes his revulsion with nineteenth century imperialism, and the effects of encounter with wild Africa for the ivory-obsessed, unprohibited Westerner. Coppola’s Marlow is Captain Benjamin J. Willard, whose mission is to assassinate the renegade Col. Willard is the veteran soldier, whose special missions have almost driven him beyond the threshold of sanity.

All wars brutalise, torture, maim, and kill, that’s all a war is. All the main characters in the movie know and accept these facts. They even glory in them. Willard, for example, never flinches at any atrocity committed in his presence. He becomes guilty of one himself when he kills a wounded Vietnamese female civilian halfway down the river. Unlike Lance, who has machine-gunned her entire family in panic, Willard shoots the woman in cold blood.

The film is not concerned with detailing a realistic and historically accurate expression of the war; it delves into the surreal and mythic landscape of American culture and the darkness of war. The key aspects for the thematic concerns of Coppola’s film are; the trauma experienced through the victim hero, the futility of American values and the unrestrained force of the American military.

In Apocalypse Now, the Americans are not in Vietnam to fight but to surf. Following the rape of Casualties of war, the sadistic Clerk tells Eriksson to remain silent, what happens in the field stays in the field. War itself is a hunt, rather than a bloody necessity. In contrast to the gung-ho Americans, the Vietnamese are usually portrayed sympathetically. Simple Vietnamese villagers are always innocents, for whom the war is a calamity. Despite an obvious emphasis on the brutality of the American army in Vietnam, there is, however no clear polarisation between the two forces as good or bad; the process of war itself is seen as a force which induces the emergence of the contained savagery in human kind. In war, men and women are not human, but simply killing machines. Savagery as a consequence of war is seen in the film, where Clean shoots the passengers of an inspected boat.

The country of Vietnam does indeed look spectacular in Apocalypse Now, but as a character, Vietnam is a body without soul. Despite the elaborate mise en scène, a sense of emptiness and rootlessness lingers in these frames. Vietnamese characters in the film are treated as set-pieces, decorations to complete the “look” of war. They are shown as peasants running away from the American soldiers, or as maimed bodies strung over tree branches and artistically strewn on Captain Willard’s path. And they are almost never seen in close-ups—the way Western characters are instantly rendered as psychologized beings. In fact, Vietnamese voices are rarely even heard, and when they are, they are bodiless, a mere aural complement to images of graphic casualties. Their non-subtitled dialogues serve less as a cultural signifier but more as a shortcut to heighten the breach between the Americans and the “strange” land they are in.

The simple fact that the Vietnam conflict is fought over political ideologies suggests the meaningless of war. The youthful innocence of the soldiers in Vietnam, whose age averaged nineteen, is also a damning criticism of the American effort – seen in the death of the boy Clean in Apocalypse Now. The protagonists of this film are children, for whom the prospect of war is a game; it is only following training, and exposure to the full horror of war that its reality becomes apparent, and the conflict between army discipline and the ethic-effacing effects of bloody slaughter take place.

In addition, the only Vietnamese speaking part in the film belongs to a south Vietnamese army translator, who gets to yammer: “This man is dirty VC! He wants water! He can drink paddy water!” This in the movie that Coppola famously declared “is not about Vietnam – it is Vietnam”. This movie, then, is really about a bunch of pale guys, Coppola included, wading into their own hearts of darkness. It is certainly not about Vietnam. Audience can’t be even sure it’s a Vietnam war movie.

Near the beginning of the film, Captain Willard’s superior waxes poetic on the good and the evil within every human being, and the tragedy of Colonel Kurtz who was once a humanitarian and is now completely overcome by immorality and vainglory. This sentiment is reflected later in the French plantation scene when Madam Sarrault whispers in Captain Willard’s ears about his two selves: “one that kills and one that loves.” The film views Vietnam as a mythical land full of unknowable, exotic forces, implying that not just the war but the country itself possesses some power to cast the American soldiers into the dark side.

This fabrication of an inspired atrocity by the Viet Cong is consistent with the movie’s preoccupation with the dark primitives. With Heart of Darkness as its ideological ballast, this is inevitable. In Conrad’s novel, the boat goes upstream towards “the earliest beginnings of the world”. Along the way they encounter Africans with “faces like grotesque masks”. One man is compared to “a dog in a parody of breeches and a feather hat walking on his hind legs”. In Apocalypse Now, Vietnam is more or less one continuous jungle, with corpses casually dangling from trees, and arrows and spears flying out of the foliage. The arrow attack scene is lifted straight from Heart of Darkness, where a black river boat pilot is impaled by a spear. The phoniness of this is breathtaking. The NVA and Viet Cong did not win a modern war with arrows and spears. But a scene from a 1901 book has to be shoehorned into a 1979 movie because of Coppola’s fascination with savages.

As Willard’s boat travels up the Nung river, the only signs of civilisation are two US army bases and, in the new extended version, a French plantation. This has nothing to do with the Vietnam of reality. As anyone who has been there will say it, Vietnam is ,and was during the war, grossly overpopulated. Rivers and roads are lined with settlements. The US, by comparison, is more wild. Another thing a visitor to Vietnam can readily see is the ubiquity of the written language, that is, of civilisation. Signs and banners are everywhere. None of this is apparent in any of the panoramic shots of Apocalypse Now. Coppola hasn’t just withheld speech from the Vietnamese, he has also banned them from writing.

The river journey into Cambodia represents a further immersion into the primitive for the soldiers, their face paint and frequent explosions of conflict reflect their proximity to Kurtz, the epitome of moral and ethical degeneration, and distance from army discipline. The last bridge, built back up again each night, just to say the road’s open, suggests the futility of artificial ethical purpose in the vastness of Vietnam. Like Kurtz, Willard no longer adheres to conventional morality, but kills the injured boat woman rather than turn back. Willard’s rejection of the sanctity of human life is, however, due to a clinical military psyche, rather than Kurtz’s unsolicited and random killing of those that threaten him. Willard’s disciplinarian methods of survival force his admittance of the hypocrisy of the American effort. “We blew them up, then gave them a band aid.”

The tragedy of both Kurtzes is that they are trapped in the perverse logic of the ideology of imperialism. The ideology of imperialism assumes the absolute superiority of the oppressor. It is self-contradictory because it is based upon classifying the oppressed as morally inferior, but maintaining imperialism requires systematic barbarity, which morally degrades the imperialist. The historical response of successful imperialists to this has been a special kind of hypocrisy embodied in an attempt at creating distance between actor and act, perpetrator and victim. Both Kurtzes are destroyed by their moral integrity. They honestly admit their depravity to themselves. This grants them great power in facilitating imperial strategic aims but forces them to acknowledge the lie at the heart of imperialist ideology that legitimised the strategy, rendering their acts purposeless. The honesty of their conduct undermines the imperialist ideology. The honesty of their undertakings causes the managers to increasingly perceive Kurtz as a threat and identify him with the ‘savages’ they are supposed to be ‘civilising’. Kurtz challenges the hypocrisy of the ideology of imperialism precisely insofar as he helps it achieve its true aims.

This film, then, is not about the horrors of the jungle but its allures. The jungle becomes a hotbed of wild desires, where you can hobnob with savages, shoot them, get shot in turns, burn down acres of forests and get scared by tigers. It becomes, in short, the ultimate theme park. Halfway through this romp, Lance sums it all up, “This is better than Disneyland!” Anything to get away from “The horror, the horror” of home. “The horror, the horror” that is uttered by Kurtz in Heart of Darkness does not refer to the horrors of the jungle, as some believe, but the horrors of daily life anywhere. That is a much more profound point. In Conrad’s book, Kurtz leaves his English wife only to shack up with an African one. He becomes “at home” in the jungle. Fleeing one domestic arrangement, he runs right into another.

It is meaningful that Kurtz got into trouble for murdering four south Vietnamese “double agents”. Unlike the Vietnamese double agents, they are not two-faced. To be a double agent, one has to be sly, deceitful, hypocritical – mental operations these folks are apparently not capable of performing. In fact, they seem incapable of speech: none of them has a single line in the movie. The montagnards are so simple, so childlike, they can be scared away with sirens. Hard to square that with the fearless warriors supposedly undaunted by artilleries and napalm strikes. Fulfilling the white man’s fantasy, they worship Kurtz like a god, and after he is killed by Willard, they are ready to prostrate themselves before him too.

In Apocalypse Now, Willard is the product of moral-effacing indoctrination; he is an assassin, a professional killer, and is quite able to shoot the wounded Vietnamese girl, rather than endanger his mission by seeking medical aid. The mission to terminate Kurtz tests his allegiance to duty and military necessity, but it is also a testament to psychological conditioning that he is finally able to terminate Kurtz’s command. Kurtz asks Willard if he is an assassin, “Kurtz, Are you an assassin?. Willard, I’m a soldier.” Kurtz’s psychological breakdown does not arise entirely from a survival or killer instinct, unleashed by his experiences, but also from a scepticism those experiences have fostered – in the supposed validity and morality of Western ethics, and the sanctity of human life itself. His display of Vietnamese heads on sticks, and presentation of the head of chef to Willard, demonstrates this moral degeneration, “I am beyond morality, above caring.”

The degeneration of Kurtz illustrates the amorality of the American establishment, an inner beastilaity elemental to the civilised psyche, which is constantly exploited by the filmmakers in their portrayal of supposedly civilised atrocities, and in the predatory mercantile culture of American capitalism. Kurtz is not only the avatar of an innate western primitive, but also of its results following the subjection of Americans to one of the bloodiest wars in american history.

If the establishment-questioning hero of Apocalypse Now is Willard, The anti-hero of the film is certainly Kurtz, whose descent into barbarism is the product of western ideological aggression. Like the cattle, Kurtz is sacrificed by the system that bred him for no other cause than an ideological dispute. The self-effacing nature of the imperfect civilised psyche, is reflected in the ruins of ancient structures in Kurtz’s village. The film ends with The Door’s The End, suggesting a warning to the apocalyptic prospect of nuclear war for the ideologically divided civilised world.

In conclusion,  the film has one major aspect which is the madness of a war fought over the trivial conflict between ideals. The ensuing conflict is not so much a mutual defence against the other, but an intolerance of each other’s views. The main critique of the Vietnam war is not so much its ethical basis, but the manner in which it was fought, using massive indiscriminate bombardment, resulting in massive civilian casualties. The naive, polar conceptions of war, and of the political systems that fought in Vietnam are also attacked in the films. Perhaps the films’ most controversial aspect, however, lies in its condemnation of an establishment that breaks down individuality, imposing a regimented, and indoctrinated psychology on its citizens, committing all kinds of atrocities and folly in the mindless preservation of the ideal.

Bibliography:

  1. (2014). AN ANALYSIS OF APOCALYPSE NOW. Available: https://cinescribbler.wordpress.com/2014/01/30/an-analysis-of-apocalypse-now/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. A Level Film Studies – Focus Film Factsheet. (2017). Apocalypse Now . Available: http://resource.download.wjec.co.uk.s3.amazonaws.com/vtc/2016-17/16-17_1-19/_eng/apocalypse-now.pdf. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. CORDELL STRUG. (1995). Apocalypse Now What? Apocalyptic Themes in Modern Movies. Available: https://wordandworld.luthersem.edu/content/pdfs/15-2_Revelation/15-2_Strug.pdf. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. English Language and Literature Studies. (2019). Imperialist Ideology and Kurtz in Heart of Darkness and Apocalypse Now. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333331866_Imperialist_Ideology_and_Kurtz_in_Heart_of_Darkness_and_Apocalypse_Now. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. Linh Dinh. (2001). Apocalypse lies. Available: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2001/nov/02/artsfeatures.londonfilmfestival2001. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  6. Paul Catherall. (2013). Comment on the explicit or implicit ideological and moral basis for one or more Hollywood films of the same genre, and on how its stance is conveyed through narrative, characterisation and/ or mise-en. Available: http://www.draigweb.co.uk/draigweb/comment-on-the-explicit-or-implicit-ideological-and-moral-basis-for-one-or-more-hollywood-films-of-the-same-genre-and-on-how-its-stance-is-conveyed-through-narrative. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  7. Phuong Le. (2019). Feeling Seen: Whose Apocalypse Now?. Available: https://www.filmcomment.com/blog/feeling-seen-whose-apocalypse-now/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  8. Susan Jolliffe Napier. (1995). Apocalypse Now, The floodwaters have come unto my soul my . In: Escape from the Wasteland: Romanticism and Realism in the Fiction of Mishima Yukio and Oe Kenzaburo. Google Books: Harvard Univ Asia Center. 131-143.

The Avant-Garde and “cinematic experimentation”

Avant-garde is a movement that seeks to break the tradition and politicise the issues. The theoretical approach to cinema addressed the issues like realist versus naturalist films, spectator-screen relationship, editing styles, subjectivity, and psychoanalytical potential of a film, auteur cinema and the semiotics of the film. With this, filmmakers turned to making film with experimentation as its central part. This report discusses how the avant-garde is exemplified in Rubber and La Jetee films.

Chris Marker composed La Jetee in1962 which is almost entirely of still shots. The film has the theme of time, memory, and perception, and it tells an elaborate science fiction story, which ultimately deals with the perceived illusion of cinematic movement. “The human brain forgets the cuts,” Michel Gondry said about film. And just like Michael Haneke calls the 24 frames in each cinema second “24 lies,” Chris Marker emphasises the false perception of film movement  by simply slowing down the pace of the still images.

La Jetee is an experimental time travel film, but temporality and movement are opposed visually with the still images. The film emphasises the illusion of time lapse and movement perceived both by the characters within the film and the audience of the film. It achieves the feeling of movement and time lapse mainly through its editing. It uses dissolves, fade-ins, and fade-outs to provoke the feeling of time lapse. As more obvious and gradual transitions than a cut, dissolves, fade-ins, and fade-outs suggest longer time lapse.

The dissolve is synchronised with the sound. As the story moves from the past to the present, La Jetee creates mental continuity and rhythm through its visual and sound editing. The soundtrack serves as an editing framework which shapes the mental transitions between the sequences of the story. For example, in one of the sequences when the main character is in the past, music is running along the voice-over. As the character “falls back exhausted,” a shot of the woman’s face dissolves to the character’s face back in the laboratory. Music stops at the moment of the dissolve, but begins again when the scientists “probably give him another shot” and the character returns back in the past.

The German voices are the only direct speech in the film, and they are intentionally vague, inaudible, and incomprehensible. The fact that neither the main character, nor the woman say anything in direct speech makes the audience feel them lifeless and detached from present. None of the characters in La Jetee have a name either. They seem voiceless and lifeless figures frozen in time. Their black-and-white photographs enhance the feeling of lifelessness.

The live-action sequence consists of the woman blinking—a subtle movement which can be easily overlooked. Right before the blinking, a long series of slow dissolves show the woman sleeping in bed. The dissolves are so numerous that at times it appears as if the woman is alive and moving. Just like the main character cannot tell if he moves or has simply made it up, the audience cannot distinguish between the woman is still or moving.

La Jetee tells the story of a man who sees his own death as a child without realising it. He lives his life (presumably), only to find out the moment that has marked his entire life is the memory of his own death. From a philosophical point of view, La Jetee is an existentialist tale of doomed existence, inevitability, and predetermined death. And the best way to express this idea is by using lifeless photographs to tell the story of a life that is only perceived as such.

The cinematographic, representational economy conveys a bourgeois, anti-materialist consciousness, which the avant-garde film alone is able to purpass, or at least to portray in critical self-reflection. As a consequence, in La Jetee, the incestuous desire of a protagonist watching his own movie and which is under penalty of death, is the illusion-breaking self-reflective element. This ennobles La Jetee alongside its ingenious photographic composition into a unique and in itself an unrepeatable avant-garde film.

If La Jetee applies the violence of the Oedipal drama to itself, then the death of its protagonist more than anything guarantees the separation between a passive spectator and the screen and prevents a potential participative involvement in the event from taking place. If the scene of the runway reflects spectators’ Oedipal viewing position, then the incestaboo ensures that the spectator doesn’t commit illicit auto-erotic, masturbatory, or incestuous acts with either his other self or with his parents, and that he remains restricted to a viewing position separated from events, in order to acquire neutral and objective knowledge of future technologies or of the cinema, as does the Apparatus Theory itself. Le Jette and its theorising encounter the Oedipal cinema, and the ideology of a neutral and transcendental standpoint built into it, as a given fact, which every film is condemned to reproduce and which the avant-garde film can only expose.

The other example of avant-garde film is Rubber. It is a road movie in the most literal sense. It’s also a horror film, a critique of cinema past and present, an absurdist satire of traditional film tropes, an homage to David Cronenberg’s Scanners, a comeback for Eighties icon Hauser, and a feature-length avant garde film unlike any other.

“All great films, without exception, contain an important element of no reason,” explains Spinella’s deadpan desert cop Lt. Chad in the film’s intriguing, fourth-wall-shattering prologue. Rubber is a randomly vicious antagonist, a sentient tire that rolls up out of the California desert and goes on an inexplicable rampage that’s viewed from afar by a binocular-wielding “audience.” 

Rubber is a deliberately out-there provocation and such works are geared to be despised. Homicidal, telekinetic, and jealous of the less vulcanised life-forms it encounters, this steel-belted psychopath is, in its own wild way, genuinely of and on Kerouac’s Road: It is a mad one, mad to live, mad to talk or, at least, communicate, mad to be saved, and “desirous of everything at the same time.” And therein lies Rubber’s Achilles tread: At nearly an hour and a half, it’s a mighty long stretch of two-lane blacktop for a Dada-esque prank that could’ve been considerably more substantive – not to mention subversive – had it been worn into an explosive 20-minute short.


The film is a demonstration of the concept of “no reason,” it opens in the California desert with a cop (Stephen Spinella) stepping out of his police cruiser and addressing the camera directly. As for the sentient tire, it comes to life in the desert, discovers it has the power to kill scorpions and bunnies through telekinesis, and then proceeds to stalk human prey. 

The avant-garde film Rubber is rife with Brechtian allusions that call attention to the movie-making apparatus, filled with broad philosophical musings about scopophilia and other stalwarts of film theory, it sometimes feels like the narrative version of a long-winded film studies class tinged with a love of grandiose conceptual absurdity.

Still, the movie offers plenty for the 99.999 percent of the audience that don’t spend their free time debating the relative merits of feminist film theory or devouring Christian Metz. The picture thrills in large part because the filmmaker so gleefully indulges in the craziness of the conceit, mirroring the tire’s deadly advance across a barren American desert with the plight of onscreen spectators perched on lawn chairs, binoculars in hand, devouring the spectacle and debating what it all means.

The experience inspires feelings of incredulousness, the stark disbelief only provoked by works of art that dare to step boldly outside the mainstream. The sort of self-reflexive dialogue that comprises much of the production could easily register as smarmy, too cute self-absorptive schlock, but Dupieux and the actors ably tread the tenuous line between the fresh and the pretentious. Their philosophical musings about the nature of storytelling have a spontaneity to them that spurs charmed recognition rather than grating eye-rolls.

At the same time, Dupieux uses carefully-timed takes and some tire-level camera placement to transform Robert into a scary, sinister figure. There’s real tension in his rage-filled vibrations, which are spurred at the slightest provocation and which through some sort of psychic energy cause the spontaneous combustion of his antagonists. He’s a tire with a personality, obsessed by a French tourist lodging at a seedy motel.

This is a smart and incisive cinematic experiment. Whether people ultimately love it or hate it, or can’t imagine seeing a movie about a tire, it’s unique enough to deserve their consideration.

Bibliography:

  1. (2014). Avant-Garde. Available: https://www.filmtheory.org/avant-garde/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Lamos Ignoramous. Chris Marker’s La Jetee Analysis: Mortality and the Illusion of Time. Available: http://filmslie.com/chris-marker-la-jetee-analysis-temporality/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. Scott Tobias. (2011). Rubber. Available: https://film.avclub.com/rubber-1798167773. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. MARC SAVLOV. (2011). Rubber. Available: https://www.austinchronicle.com/events/film/2011-04-01/rubber/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. Robert Levin. (2011). Review: ‘Rubber’ Aims its WTF For The Head But Not the Heart. Available: https://filmschoolrejects.com/review-rubber-aims-its-wtf-for-the-head-but-not-the-heart-5662428b7d17/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  6. (2006). La Jetee (1962). In: Todd Fraley, Anandam P. Kavoori Media, Terrorism, and Theory: A Reader. Google Books: Rowman & Littlefield. 56-66.

Audience Theories /Passive, Active and Reception/

The audience receives the creative work done and perceives its content in either similar or different. The meaning of the message can change in the way they see it fit according to their social context. The encoded messages usually contain shared rules and symbols common with other people. So the encoder, sender, has to think how the receiver will perceive the message. Then, decoding would be a successful delivery only if the message sent by the encoder is understood completely to its content as it was intended.

The messages sent with verbal/non-verbal cues and gestures don’t bring the same result always as intended by the sender, bringing an altogether different meaning an insight to the concept sent. Thus, the distortion occurs when the audience cannot understand the concept of having a different take on the conclusion itself. Such distortion can be because of the age, gender, religion, race, political views, ethnicity, class, culture and the mood in which the audience receives the message etc..

Everyone has been in an audience. So the audience is part of the media equation – a product is produced and an audience receives it. Researchers investigating the effect of media on audiences have considered the audience in different distinct ways.

The cultural theorist, Stuart Hall, explored how people make sense of media texts and claimed audiences were active not passive. An active audience engages, interprets and responds to a media text in different ways and is capable of challenging the ideas encoded in it. While a passive audience is more likely to accept the messages encoded in a media text without challenge and are therefore more likely to be directly affected by the messages.

The earliest idea was that a mass audience is passive and inactive. The members of the audience are seen as couch potatoes just sitting there consuming media texts – particularly commercial television programmes. It was thought that this did not require the active use of the brain. The audience accepts and believes all messages in any media text that they receive. This is the passive audience model.

Here appeared The Hypodermic Model. In this model the media is seen as powerful and able to inject ideas into an audience who are seen as weak and passive. It was thought that a mass audience could be influenced by the same message. This appeared to be the case in Nazi Germany in the 1930s leading up to the second world war. Powerful German films such as Triumph of the Will seemed to use propaganda methods to ‘inject’ ideas promoting the Nazi cause into the German audience. That is why this theory is known as the Hypodermic model.

It suggests that a media text can ‘inject’ ideas, values and attitudes into a passive audience who might then act upon them. This theory also suggests that a media text has only one message which the audience must pick up. And basically, this theory stems from a fear of the mass media, and gives the media much more power than it can ever have in a democracy. Also it ignores the obvious fact that not everyone in an audience behaves in the same way. It’s impossible for an audience to be passive! For instance, I disagree with most political shows’ content and don’t like Marvel’s movies.ذ

This model owes much to the supposed power of the mass media – in particular film – to inject their audiences with ideas and meanings. It is worth noting that totalitarian states and dictatorships are similar in their desire to have complete control over the media, usually in the belief that strict regulation of the media will help in controlling entire populations. The effects model has several variants and despite the fact that it is an outdated model it continues to exert influence in present debates about censorship and control in the media.

The Frankfurt School developed concerns about the power which modern mass media had to propagandise on behalf of fascism. They articulated criticisms of a capitalist system in America which controlled media output, creating a stupefying mass culture that eliminated or marginalised opposition or alternatives.

Most of the classical film theories developed in the 1960s and 1970s, including structuralist, auteurist, formalist, Marxist, and psychoanalytic theories, argue that the text is the site of meaning. These theories are concerned with how viewers are affected by films, but the audiences they describe are comprised of idealised, homogeneous spectators who all react to films in the same way, regardless of differences in race, gender, and other identifying factors. ISAs, on the other hand, function through ideology and work by enticing individuals to accept subject positions which benefit the dominant classes and perpetuate capitalism. 

Althusser’s theory of the media as an ideological state apparatus was embraced by classical film theorists, who examine the ways that the cinema influences spectators by analysing the cinematic texts. A major criticism of classical theories, then, is that the spectator is a historical and idealised, and plays no role in the creation of a film’s meaning. Reception theory rejects this classical construction of the spectator, and instead focuses on viewers in the material world, and how they have actually read and understood media texts.

Because of their interest in film as a medium for ideology, classical film theories are overwhelmingly text activated, operating from the assumption that meaning is created in the text and that the text determines the viewer’s response. An alternate theoretical viewpoint is reader activated, which examines the features of readers and how those features affect the reading experience. While reader activated theories account for varying interpretations among readers, however, they still tend to make generalisations about individual interactions with texts and not to contextualise the reading experience. 

Janet Staiger proposes a third approach, a context-activated model which looks at the historical circumstances surrounding reception to place the reader/spectator in context. Context-activated theories examine everything from the individual’s subject position to the text’s mode of production and the circumstances of exhibition. The sum of these events gives meaning to the viewing or reading experience. 

The audience, then, is not uniform as in classical film theory, but rather heterogeneous and capable of interpreting a text’s messages in a multitude of ways based on contextual factors. 

Inoculation or Culmination Model, a theory suggests that long-term exposure to repeated media messages makes audiences “immune” to them. Thus for example, prolonged exposure to media violence would desensitise the audience so that they would no longer be shocked by it and therefore might be more likely to commit a violent act.

The problems with the effects model, in whatever form, have to do with its roots in behaviourist psychology. The behaviourist explanation of human behaviour is looking increasingly hard to justify as we have come to develop a fuller understanding of the complexities of human behaviour, which is not predictable nor is it controllable. There are also the difficulties of linking cause and effect in terms of how we engage with media texts. The large number of studies that have been done do not prove the case conclusively either way.

This model, it seems, is something of an anachronism but it is constantly revived by politicians and social commentators when moral panics are generated around issues such as ‘video nasties’ and their influence on children (eg the Bulger case) or computer games allegedly damaging literacy skills or contributing to violent behaviour (eg the Doom-computer game).

Katz and Lazarsfeld assume a slightly more active audience, which is Flow Theory. It suggests messages from the media move in two distinct ways. First, individuals who are opinion leaders, receive messages from the media and pass on their own interpretations in addition to the actual media content. The information does not flow directly from the text into the minds of its audience, but is filtered through the opinion leaders who then pass it on to a more passive audience. The audience then mediates the information received directly from the media with the ideas and thoughts expressed by the opinion leaders, thus being influenced not by a direct process, but by a two step flow.

The idea of this theory is that whatever our experience of the media we will be likely to discuss it with others and if we respect their opinion, the chances are that we will be more likely to be affected by it. This theory appeared to reduce the power of the media, and some researchers concluded that social factors were also important in the way in which audiences interpret texts. This led to the idea of active audiences.

Active Audiences, a newer model sees the audience not as couch potatoes, but as individuals who are active and interact with the communication process and use media texts for their own purposes. We behave differently because we are different people from different backgrounds with many different attitudes, values, experiences and ideas. This model is now generally considered to be a better and more realistic way to talk about audiences.

A more recent model of audience is that of The Uses and Gratifications. It suggests there are certain reasons why an audience responds to different media texts. In this model the individual has the power and she selects the media texts that best suit her needs and her attempts to satisfy those needs. The psychological basis for this model is the hierarchy of needs identified by Maslow. Among the chief exponents of this model are McQuail and Katz.

The assumption of this model is that audiences are always active. It does not take account of the fact that a viewer may watch a TV programme or a movie because they can’t be bothered to turn it off. Similarly they might look at an advertising poster because there is no other around. They do not have the choice of a poster that satisfies their desire for a particular representation. However, Blumier and Katz (1975) went into greater detail and identified four main uses.

Firstly, diversion, which is the need for escape, entertainment and relaxation. All types of television programmes can be ‘used’ to wind down and offer diversion, as well as satisfying some of the other needs at the same time. Audiences consume media texts to escape from their everyday lives. They choose entertaining texts that allow them to divert their attention from the real world, perhaps by watching a fantasy film like Harry Potter or reading a fashion magazine like Vogue. Secondly, information and education when some media texts are consumed by audiences when they want to be informed and educated. Newspapers, news programmes and current affairs documentaries educate and inform. They help the audience to find out what is happening in the world. By keeping up to date with news about local and international events people feel they have the knowledge to avoid or deal with dangers.

Thirdly, social interaction or personal relationships when some media texts like The X Factor or I’m a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here provoke interaction with the audience. It’s the need to interact with other people. This is provided by forming virtual relationships with characters in soaps, films and all kinds of drama, and other programmes and other media texts. Social media can now spark an immediate reaction and get people talking while the action is still happening. Finally, personal identity when some audiences like to watch or read media texts because they can compare their life experiences with those represented in it. It’s the need to define their identity and sense of self. Part of their sense of self is informed by making judgements about all sorts of people and things. This is also true of judgements they make about TV and film characters, and celebrities. Their choice of music, the shows they watch, the stars they like can be an expression of their identities. One aspect of this type of gratification is known as value reinforcement. This is where they choose television programmes or newspapers that have similar beliefs to those they hold. Audience pleasure comes from empathising and identifying with characters or content represented in them. Soap operas or lifestyle magazines can offer audiences this kind of enjoyment.

Reception analysis is an active audience theory that looks at how audiences interact with a media text taking into account their ‘situated culture’, this is their daily life. A further development about how audiences read a text was put forward by Professor Stuart Hall in ‘encoding/decoding’ in 1980. Social and daily experiences can affect the way an audience reads a media text and reacts to it. Hall suggests that an audience has a significant role in the process of reading a text, and this can be discussed in three different ways:

The dominantor preferred reading, it can be seen as a hegemonic reading. The audience shares the code of the text and fully accepts its preferred meaning as intended by the producers.  when the audience responds to the ideas in the way the media producer wants them to. For a programme like The Voice UK or The X Factor this could be large scale audience voting and the purchase of the winning singer’s single. The audience takes in the work as given by the director with no extra notes attached. Example, in the Harry Potter Series, Lord Voldemort is a bad guy, and how have the media producers have conveyed it with a bald head, black cloak, sunken eyes, cold and cruel voice, and threatening presence to his surroundings.

The negotiated reading, when the audience responds by accepting and rejecting certain elements. Perhaps voting for the underdog in a talent competition or questioning the programme via social media platforms. The audience partly shares the code of the text and broadly accepts the preferred meaning, but will change the meaning in some way according to their own experiences, culture and values. For instance, these audience members might argue that some representations, ethnic minorities perhaps, appear to them to be inaccurate. So the audiences who thought they know and are aware of the acts made in the film are bad and not right but get on to accept that it is fine because there is a reason behind it. Thus accepting the author’s message even though it goes against the audiences’ personal convictions. For example, many episodes in The Simpsons series have contents that are against my personal views but I still watch, enjoy and accept the content given.

And finally the oppositional reading, when the audience understands the preferred meaning but does not share the text’s code and rejects this intended meaning and constructs an alternative meaning. They have no acceptance for the author’s takes on the concept of the film or the subject it handled.For instance, the campaign to stop the winner of The X Factor getting to Christmas number one in the charts. This can be called a radical reading that may be, say Marxist or feminist or right wing who rejects the values and ideology of the preferred reading. It can be morally wrong, emotionally disturbing, unnecessary adult contents of violence and blood gore, religious belief, political outlooks etc., which will make the audience reject the idea. A final example, in 1970-1980 was an era in Indian Films they showed smoking as a sign of prestige, image, wealth, power and flourishing happiness whereas, the reality states otherwise, for it causes cancer.

More recent developments still suggest that there is a decoding process going on among the active audience who are not simply using the media for gratification purposes. All readings of texts is a semiological approach because it recognises the importance of the analysis of signs, particularly visual signs, that shape so much of modern media output.

Overall the shift in the models for the audience has gone from mass audience to individual viewer with stress on the active audience rather than the passive model. The level of activity in the implied audience is related to the uses, pleasures, cultural competence, situation and available technology for the particular audience.

Additionally, there are the interactive audiences. The interactive role of audiences in programmes where audience participation is asked is increasing. Audiences are asked to be a voter (X factor and Big Brother) or as an on screen member of an audience (Children in Need) or as a participant (Who wants to be a millionaire). This can be seen as audience power, but I don’t think that this is real. Sometimes the power of the audience seems to lie in being able to take part in a media text.

More and more documentary style programmes are made about so-called ‘real’ people doing things that in the past would have been done by professional presenters, such as the Faking it series. The audience is even more active than ever before. It is becoming part of the production. Audiences seem to like seeing themselves on any genre of programme from daytime confrontational help programmes (Trisha, Oprah) to Diet Doctors.

Reception Theory can be seen as an extension of the Uses and Gratifications Model. It concentrates on the audience themselves and how they come to a text. The idea is that the audience themselves help to create the meaning of text and this depends on their social values, gender, age, class, context of time in which we are living.

Another important point that came from this research is that there are clear differences in the uses that people made of the media in their everyday lives depending on gender. He found that men prefer factual programmes, while women prefer fiction. Also, men prefer watching the programmes extensively whereas women tend to be doing something else at the same time. Finally he found that if someone had control over what the family was watching it tended to be the man – often with the remote control in his hand. However, I don’t agree with this point as I choose what we watch most of the time, not my husband.

Still in line with the active audience idea is the concept of Mode of Address. This refers to the way that a text speaks to the audience in a style that encourages them to identify with the text because it is ‘their’ kind of text. For example, Friends is intended for a young audience because of the way it uses music and the opening credits to develop a sense of fun, energy and enthusiasm that the perceived audience can identify with. This does not mean that other groups are excluded, merely that the dominant mode of address is targeted at the young.

The framework of dominant, negotiated, and oppositional readings is not without problems, however. Because viewers can hold multiple positions towards a film text at once, most every reading becomes negotiated; in fact, the tripartite framework has since been replaced by a continuum ranging from dominant to oppositional. 

Although the use of reception analysis for the purposes of censorship and marketing has contributed to film theorists’ distrust of reception theory, reception theory has recently gained acceptance and is now acknowledged to be an important method of analysing how audiences experience and interpret films. Audiences watching M*A*S*H (1972) at the height of the Vietnam War, or those viewing Fahrenheit 9/11 (2004) during the buildup to that year’s US presidential election, would understand these films based on the current social and political climates; audiences who watch these films at other historical moments would most likely have different reactions to them. Reception theory attempts to account for all of these factors in determining how audiences experience motion pictures.

These frameworks have proven useful for reception studies as a means of theorising the wide variety of interpretations and meanings that viewers take from texts. Both British cultural studies and reception theory agree that the spectator’s interaction with the text is complex, and that, unlike the passive, idealised spectator found in classical film theory, viewers can and do question and oppose the ideology presented to them by media institutions.

“It is unnecessary that the audience will decode the message encoded by the author just the same”. – Stuart Hall

In conclusion, reception theory is far more complex in understanding as each mind perceives in its own way. A single person can have a mixed reaction of being a dominant, oppositional, and negotiated reader when they are going through the process of receiving the message. The content producer cannot take/judge for every single individual perspective. The conclusion taken by the audience which was/is/will be right for and their perspectives will change as when the time goes by and will feel just right for the conclusion derived at that moment.

Bibliography:

  1. Media Studies. Audience appeal. Available: https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zg24frd/revision/2. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Media Studies. Understanding Audience. Available: https://brianair.wordpress.com/film-theory/understanding-audience/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. Media Studies. Audience Theory. Available: http://media-studies.mrshollyenglish.com/theory/audiences-institutions/audience-theory. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. Media Studies. AUDIENCE THEORY. Available: http://gsmedia.weebly.com/audience-theory.html. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. Media Studies. Reception Theory. Available: https://www.communicationtheory.org/reception-theory/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  6. Kristen Anderson Wagner. Reception Theory. Available: http://www.filmreference.com/encyclopedia/Independent-Film-Road-Movies/Reception-Theory-RECEPTION-STUDIES-AND-CLASSICALFILM-THEORY.html. Last accessed 01/04/20.

Females in the Film Industry

Repeatedly, women activists in Film industry have pointed out that a perception of gender equity contradicts the statistics, which demonstrate traditional as well as ‘new’ forms of sexism. In this post-feminist context inequality is typically invisible and unspoken, and there is a thriving narrative of meritocracy based on talent and determination, where ‘you’re only as good as your last job’. Below-the-line ‘crew’ are distinguished from creatives in a hierarchy of creativity. In spite of beliefs about merit, talent and the ‘good idea’, women’s ‘good ideas’ and their work capabilities across a range of roles are less likely to be recognised and rewarded than those of men. This report will visit some statistics and opinions to debate if really there is still sexism in the industry or not.

Meetings full of male executives, action stars refusing to be directed by a woman, actors expecting a kiss .. loads of women working in the film and TV industries have experienced sexism.

Firstly, according to San Diego’s State’s Centre for the Study of Women in Television and Film, women made up only 7% of directors on the top 250 films of 2016, which was actually a 2% decline from 2015. The same study found that while women made up higher percentages of other fields in the industry — 24% of producers, or 17% of editors, for example — they only accounted for 17% of the workforce of all the jobs surveyed. And that too, was a 2% decline from the year before.

And if we look at female filmmakers, we will find that many of them are not afraid to admit that they experienced sexism. Sarah Gavron, director, said “I’ve endlessly found myself in rooms of men and had the experience of feeling I wasn’t being heard. It’s a confidence thing. We even tracked down a female sound recordist: it’s a really intimate role, standing there with the boom, especially in the strip-search scenes. I’m so aware how often women’s bodies are objectified on film.” “Brendan Gleeson, who plays a police officer in the film, joked he’s rarely worked in such an oestrogen-filled environment. He really spoke positively about it.”

Another talented director, Lexi Alexander, emphasised “I would say 99% of women working in the film and television industries have experienced sexism. I can list endless examples, from the driver who refused to take me because he was told to wait for the director (which was me) to the executives who insist they need a male director for a film about boxing and fighting, then hire a guy who never had a fight in his life, while I spent the better part of my youth being an international competitive fighting champion. Once someone said to me: “We really wanted you to direct this movie, but ‘anonymous male action star’ refuses to be directed by a woman.” “The director is considered the general, and just like in the military, they still can’t picture anyone not born with the Y chromosome with that title. The industry still insists on telling most stories from a male point of view and even if women write male-driven fare, they’re assumed to be less competent at it”  “I have met many people who are convinced that the number of female directors is so low because fewer women want to direct movies. And they say this without irony.”

Moreover, if we look at the mainstream films and Oscars & awards of big competitions and film festivals, we will know the answer to our question without thinking. Is there really still sexism in the industry?

“We do have 13 directors nominated who are females across other categories, so everybody from Jennifer Lee who directed Frozen 2, and this is what gives me joy and hope actually, six female directors in the shorts category and that is the category where we are really seeing talent at the start of their career and they are the industry of the future but we are going to do more, we are not going to stop pushing,” she added. Bafta’s deputy chairman, Krishnendu Majumdar, said the lack of female nominees in the best director category is an “industry-wide problem”, but Bafta is “fiercely doing something about it”.

Joker leads the nominations at the British Academy Film Awards, which will be handed out on Sunday night amid “disappointment” at the lack of nominations for female directors and that all acting nominees are white. The other best director Bafta nominees are Sam Mendes for 1917, Martin Scorsese for The Irishman, Quentin Tarantino for Once Upon A Time… In Hollywood and Bong Joon-Ho for Parasite. However Little Women’s Greta Gerwig has not been nominated in the director category – a surprise for many – which is an all-male line-up, and no films made by women have been nominated in the best film category. And there is criticism that all acting nominees are white, with two nominations each for Scarlett Johansson and Margot Robbie.

While the nominees for the leading actress Bafta are Jessie Buckley for Wild Rose, Scarlett Johansson for Marriage Story, Saoirse Ronan for Little Women, Charlize Theron for Bombshell and Renee Zellweger for Judy. Margot Robbie scored two nominations in the supporting actress category for her roles in Bombshell and Once Upon A Time… In Hollywood.The other nominees are Laura Dern for Marriage Story, Scarlett Johansson for Jojo Rabbit and Florence Pugh for Little Women. Bafta chief executive Amanda Berry has said it is “disappointing” that all of the acting nominees for this year’s film awards are white and there are no female directors recognised. She said: “Being totally honest we are disappointed and that is not to take anything away from the people who have been nominated.”

Additionally, the cinematographer Agnès Godard said “Gradually the situation has improved but there is a limit: above certain budgets, maybe €13m (£9.5m), there are no women DoPs on big productions. It’s hard not to think that this isn’t related to sexism.”

Also, Ellen Kuras, another cinematographer, had a similar opinion. “Until recently, women represented less than 1% of all cinematographers. Now there are many more, but progress has been slow and double standards persist. I’ve heard, for example, that if a male director is being picky, people say he has a strong vision. With a woman, people will say she is being difficult.” “Women directors have traditionally found more opportunities in independent cinema, where the focus is more on making good films than box office.”

A new study out of San Diego State University has found that 2019 was an impressive year for women in film. The year brought the number of female leads to a recent historic high of 40%—a 9% increase from last year. But female characters also spoke less at the movies last year; only 34% of all speaking roles went to women, a decrease of 1%.

According to the new study, last year brought real gains for sole female protagonists in studio features. In 2018, the paper notes, women were more than twice as likely to appear in indie films than studio projects—but this year the gap narrowed, with 45% of female protagonists showing up in studio films and 55% making their appearances in indies. But there’s still a lot of ground to be gained in the major character arena. Lauzen defines such roles as “appearing in more than one scene and are instrumental to the action of the story.” Men played 63% of these characters, Lauzen writes, while women played 37%. And in the end, film goers were almost twice as likely to see male characters speak in last year’s films as they were to see women speak. Female characters also skewed younger than male characters, and a vast majority—68%—were white.

In conclusion, there are still far more men than women working in almost every field in the film industry, and it’s not because women aren’t interested in those jobs. There are not enough films with female protagonists or characters who are more than the obligatory wife, girlfriend or assistant. There are also plenty of parts written for men over 40 and very few for their female counterparts. And yet there has been a flowering of brilliant female writers and directors: Carol Morley, Destiny Ekaragha, Amma Asante, Debbie Tucker Green… So we must recognise we have these fantastic women coming through who have the power to shape the industry. And it’s because it’s packed with these really intelligent women that the voices are louder at the moment, as Amanda Nevill, chief executive in British Film Institute, mentioned.

Bibliography:

  1. Deborah Jones, Judith K. Pringle. (2015). Unmanageable Inequalities: Sexism in the Film Industry. Available: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1467-954X.12239?journalCode=sora. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Elizabeth Day, Liz Hoggard, Kathryn Bromwich. (2015). ‘99% of women working in the film and TV industries have experienced sexism’. Available: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2015/sep/27/sexism-film-industry-stories. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. ANNE COHEN. (2017). Have Things Really Gotten Better For Women In Hollywood?. Available: https://www.refinery29.com/en-gb/2017/10/176150/melissa-silverstein-women-hollywood-gender-inequality. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. Paul Glynn. (2020). Record number of female film leads, US study suggests. Available: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-51046200. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. (2020). https://www.itv.com/news/2020-01-07/bafta-nominations-2020-disappointment-lack-of-diversity-joker-leads-nominations/. Available: https://www.itv.com/news/2020-01-07/bafta-nominations-2020-disappointment-lack-of-diversity-joker-leads-nominations/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  6. Helena Asprou. (2020). ‘Joker’ composer Hildur Guðnadóttir is first woman to win ‘Best Score’ at Golden Globes. Available: https://www.classicfm.com/music-news/golden-globes-2020-joker-rocketman-soundtracks/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  7. LAURA BRADLEY. (2020). It’s Not Just The Irishman: Women Talked Less in 2019 Films. Available: https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2020/01/study-women-lead-roles-speaking-roles-martha-lauzen-sdsu. Last accessed 01/04/20.

Auteur Theory and “challenges to the auteur canon”

– Christopher Nolan –

According to Bazin “… Directors are the authors of the film and should create their own signature style and not be totally influenced by the script given.” Even though there are no specific definitions for Auteur Theory it can be said that – the films reflect the personal ideas and styles of the director or director is the author of the work. A director must exhibit certain characteristics of style, which serve as his signature, so this is that ability to look at a shot and go, “Oh that is totally Hitchcock!”

Christopher Nolan, is one of the few directors who can walk into a Hollywood studio with an idea and come out with $200m. As his career progressed from hit-to-hit, Nolan has been increasingly described by journalists as a ‘Blockbuster auteur’. I consider Nolan to be a true auteur, working with constant themes of identity, truth and time, whilst also collaborating with recurrent actors, producers, production members and writers.

Labelled “Hitchcock’s successor” by Telegraph writer Will Lawrence. Though many critics have remarked Nolan’s auteur status being unjust; of his feature films he has directed, six have been either remakes, adaptations, or franchise films. Michael Caine, who’s appeared in six of Nolan’s films, including Interstellar, said; “He reminds me of Hitchcock, the way that everything is about creating the best moments of suspense.” Nolan fits within the bracket of a “complete filmmaker” in all aspects of pre-production, production and post-production. He prefers to control the directorial process; no second directing unit, just him and the camera. This is unnatural in the world of Hollywood blockbusters as the majority of directors prefer to work on audience favour ability with constant explosions.

Nolan has an auteur approach, placing emphasis on his characters and the audience’s relationship over their actions; although the fantasy element plays an important role too, they’re always realistically grounded. Excluding his The Dark Knight trilogy, Nolan’s movies require extensive historical backstories and factual information to support their looping plots which stimulate his overall time shifting signatures, whether this be the progression of time, or the idea of time as a theme for the narrative. The films’ stylistic and thematic attributes have similarities to Nolan’s past and present work. Nolan uses the story of Bruce Wayne to examine our own personal and social identities, harping onto memory and personality as key themes which have been represented in other Nolan films. He uses this with the constant use of his themes, tones and stories that are intellectual, philosophical and sophisticated as well as entertaining.

Nolan is a director that searches for a technical challenge in film-making, productions that connect the audience to his stories. An example of his is preference on shooting on location rather than creating a set. He says he is inspired by “the claustrophobia, the restrictions involved in trying to make your story work in a real location, versus the anything-goes mentality on sets.” He embodies this within his auteur signature. Looked upon as an auteur filmmaker, Nolan’s distinctive style frequently showcases arresting cityscapes, muted colours, modern architecture and multifaceted plot-lines running in parallel with each other. Aesthetically, he typically prefers striking shadows, documentary style lighting and natural locations rather than the constricted setting of studio work. Additionally he often uses the camera to its full-capacity, attempting to create as many of his special effects as he can, rather than creating them within the post production edit. The acting, the plot, special effects, advancing film technology and sound all contribute to his growing wealth of film logic in the audience and his auteur signature. “I have a faith,” he said, “that any audience can tell the difference between something that’s consistent to rules versus something that’s totally made up and anarchic.”

If you are watching a Christopher Nolan film, there are few things to look for that would identify it. Let’s call them Nolan’s trademarks as a director. Non-Linear Storytelling is the first one. What Nolan is probably best known for is that he doesn’t tell his stories linearly. He makes extensive use of flashbacks and flash-forwards to add additional depth and explanation. As such, a common theme is having multiple story threads that link together. In Memento, for example, the story is told from both ends at the same time. In The Prestige, the film is split into two stories that are from the perspectives of two different characters, and as events in one story-line occur, they add clarity to events that happen in the other. Nearly, all of Nolan’s films have an opening scene or at least just a clip of a scene that is not in chronological order with the rest of the film. For instance, in Memento, the opening sequence is the last scene played backwards and in Interstellar it’s there is a flash forward to clips of an interview, then a clip of flashback/dream.

Also, in many of Nolan’s films, a main character starts off with redeeming qualities only to be shown later as having evil qualities. These characters can be the protagonist or someone who is at first assisting the protagonist. They often start off as heroic or seem like they have good intentions, but by the end of the film are antagonists or anti-heroes. In The Prestige, the protagonist is Angier (Hugh Jackman) who plays the victim’s role when Borden (Christian Bale) causes the death of his wife. In the end though, Angier’s obsession with revenge ends up making him as much of a villain than Borden. Nolan’s Batman trilogy has one major supporting character that switches sides in each film. Ducard/Ra’s al Ghul in Batman Begins, Harvey Dent/Two Face in The Dark Knight, and Miranda Tate/Talia al Ghul in The Dark Knight Rises.

Furthermore, Nolan is an auteur director, which basically means that he has his hand in just about everything. Although stories are his forte, he also pays close attention to the manner in which his films are shot. In particular, Nolan is very careful with where he puts his camera, and what it shows the audience. This is especially true when a scene is focusing on a character or dialogue. Nolan’s favourite shot is to place the camera behind his actor at eye level. This is to allow the audience to “see” from the character’s perspective without actually being that character. It is a clever way to create a first-person like experience for the audience without giving up a third-person storytelling advantage. For example, in Inception, the vertigo-inducing fight sequence in the twisting hotel room is shot from behind Arthur. Even in his recent film, Dunkirk, he relied on a story about human frailty and the way ordinary people react to the survival impulse. The power of the cinematography simultaneously delineates vast beach-fronts, imposing air raids and the subjective point-of-view of bewildered soldiers caught up in the chaos of war. 


Shining Light is an essential signature we must talk about. Nolan uses light, darkness, and the contrast of those things to show character growth/decay and exploration. In Batman Begins it is Bruce Wayne who, with the help of a flashlight, ventures into the bat cave for the first time to face his fears. In The Prestige, it is a field of light bulbs free of wires that allows Angier to experience amazement from something real, not an illusion. In Inception, there is a ceiling of lights in the first/last scene of the movie (similar to the idea of a field of light as in The Prestige) which not only captivates the audience but helps them make the connection between the two very important future/past sequences. Having skilful lighting, allows Nolan to adjust and manipulate impressions that are conveyed on the screen. Nolan’s strong and clever lighting choices can be distinguished throughout all his films.

Connections is Nolan’s biggest signature. It is also the one that’s the hardest to spot. All of Nolan’s films have various levels of connections. These connections can be physical or based on ideas and themes. Some of them are obvious and therefore easy to point out (The Batman Trilogy), while others are more obscure and are just theory at this point (The Prestige Trilogy). Although Nolan’s films have made technological advances over time, production values have increased, and actors have aged, his films are remarkably consistent in presentation. The key is the people he works with. Even though The Prestige takes place in the early 20th century, the film feels eerily similar to Inception or Insomnia. Each of Nolan’s films have a connection to the film that immediately preceded it. This may be intentional or just coincidence, as some connections are stronger than others. In Memento the clock that is used in the film is the same one that is stolen in Following. Both of the main characters in Insomnia talk to the person they are after on a phone before they know who that person is. Both of them receive this phone call while in a hotel room. The beginning of Batman Begins takes place near an icy glacier, a homage to the glacier shown in the opening scene of Insomnia. Finally, The Prestige starts off with Christian Bale’s character in prison, just like Batman Begins. These are just some of the connections. There are much more, including connections between films that are not back-to-back. Examples include the fact that in both Batman Begins and Inception Ken Watanabe’s character dies by a roof caving in on him.

However, several good critiques have been made of auteur theory. The director simply can’t take all the credit of making a successful film. In his book, Andre Sarris agrees that the role of the director as an author needs expertise in the fields of technicality, signature style, and influence of personality but a movie simply cannot be made without a team effort from actors, script, camera techniques and every single detail that needs to appear on the screen. And for Nolan, he frequently collaborates with his producing-wife, Emma Thomas; she has executively produced every single one of his nine films (including Following). His brother, long-time writer partner Jonathan has worked on all-but three of Nolan’s films. Wally Pfister, his long-time Academy Award winning cinematographer has shot every single one of his films, bar Interstellar and film score legend Hans Zimmer has composed his last six films, along with his editor and production designer, Lee Smith and Nathan Crowley.

Therefore, the visual texture of his films remains similar because his principle of photography (cinematographer Wally Pfister) has been the same for all of his films except The Following. The soundscape of his films remains similar because Hans Zimmer has made all of the soundtracks since Batman Begins. Each film of the Batman trilogy has a similar feel to the story because Nolan wrote them all with his brother Jonathan, who also wrote Interstellar and the short story on which Memento is based. There’s also a consistency with the people in front of the camera. Once Nolan finds an actor/actress he likes working with, he often uses them for more than one film. We can say that Nolan implements a strong impact towards the personal creative vision of his films proving his auteurship.

Looking at all these elements that make an auteur, Nolan consistently produces stunning, instantly recognisable imagery and always finds innovative ways to tell a story that is visceral and intellectual all at once and after viewing his unique signatures we can say to ourselves, “Oh yes, this is definitely a Christopher Nolan film.”

“I think audiences get too comfortable and familiar in today’s movies. They believe everything    they’re hearing and seeing. I like to shake that up.” – Christopher Nolan

Bibliography:

  1. G.S. Perno. (2014). Directors’ Trademarks: Christopher Nolan. Available: https://www.cinelinx.com/movie-news/movie-stuff/directors-trademarx-christopher-nolan/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  2. Dan Lewsey. (2017). Christopher Nolan: An Auteur, or Just Another Filmmaker?. Available: http://danlewsey.com/christophernolan/. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  3. (2020). Application of Auteur Theory to Christopher Nolan. Available: https://www.ukessays.com/essays/film-studies/application-of-auteur-theory-to-christopher-nolan.php. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  4. Mary Wild. (2017). The Auteur Rises: Christopher Nolan and Dunkirk on Film. Available: https://www.citylit.ac.uk/blog/auteur-rises-christopher-nolan-and-dunkirk-film. Last accessed 01/04/20.
  5. Jacqui Griffin. (2017). A Quick Guide To Auteur Theory. Available: https://www.filminquiry.com/quick-guide-auteur-theory/. Last accessed 01/04/20.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free